DEV Community

Discussion on: Progressive Disclosure: What, Where, When, and Why

Collapse
 
zira125 profile image
Zira •

Your three handles are a useful decomposition. I’d add a runtime check: progressive disclosure needs evidence that the intended context actually loaded. In practice I’d log a context manifest per turn (source path or skill, reason, version or hash, and token estimate) and attach it to the tool or action trace.

Then test a small canary matrix: a task that should load a rule, a task that must not load it, and a cross-boundary task that should retrieve it explicitly. Otherwise a lean root can look healthy while silently omitting the payment rule, or loading two conflicting ones.

The time axis also deserves a contract. If retrieval happens mid-task, freeze and record the rule set for the current plan, or force re-validation before a risky edit. That avoids a run changing policy halfway through. The useful metric is not just token reduction; compare instruction-following and rework under controlled tasks. Progressive disclosure is a loading strategy, not proof that the loaded rules were sufficient or obeyed.

Collapse
 
cleverhoods profile image
Gábor Mészáros Reporails •

nice approach, will also touch on that on the later articles in the series. And yes, I completely agree with "Progressive disclosure is a loading strategy, not proof that the loaded rules were sufficient or obeyed."