DEV Community

alapha888
alapha888

Posted on

Pay off the $4,100 card first, or save for a house down payment first? The order costs 42 months

Same debt as the earlier examples: $4,100 on a card at 18.9% APR, paying $200 a month, no new charges. Paid on time, that takes 25 months and $890 of interest, $4,990 total.

Now a different question about the same $4,100: you also want to buy a house, and you need a $20,000 down payment. You have $200 a month to put toward one goal or the other. Which goes first — the card, or the down payment? The intuitive answer is to split it, half to each, so both move. The arithmetic says the split is the worst of the three orders, by a wide margin.

The three orders, on the same $200 a month

The down payment side earns 4.5% in a high-yield savings account. Saving $200 a month at 4.5% reaches $20,000 in 86 months. Saving $100 a month takes 150 months — the interest helps, but not that much.

Order A, card first: pay $200 a month to the card for 25 months, $890 of interest, done. Then save $200 a month for 86 months. Debt-free and $20,000 saved in 111 months total, a little over nine years.

Order B, split it: $100 a month to the card, $100 a month to savings. The card at $100 a month takes 67 months and $2,541 of interest — the slower payment nearly triples the interest, because the balance stays high while the rate stays 18.9%. At month 67 the card is finally gone and the savings account holds about $7,600. Now save $200 a month for the remaining $12,400, which takes another 86 months. Debt-free and $20,000 saved in 153 months total — 42 months later than paying the card first, and $1,651 more card interest paid for the privilege.

Order C, save first: save $200 a month for 86 months and reach the $20,000 while the card sits on minimum payments. The card on minimums takes 202 months and $5,394 of interest, as the earlier minimum-payment post priced it. You get the house keys at month 86 — and keep paying the card for another 116 months after that, at a total interest cost $4,504 higher than paying the card first. The house arrives on the same schedule as order A, but the card follows you into it for nearly ten more years.

The split feels balanced and costs the most. The reason is the rate gap: 18.9% against 4.5%. Every dollar that goes to savings while the card is unpaid earns 4.5% and lets a dollar of card balance keep costing 18.9%. The gap is 14.4 points, and it compounds against you for every month the card survives.

The second cost: the mortgage rate

There is a cost beyond the card interest. A card at 82% utilization — $4,100 on a $5,000 limit — drags the credit score down for as long as it sits there, as the earlier credit-score post showed. The score does not recover until the balance drops, and the biggest improvement comes near the end of the payoff, not the beginning.

That matters because the mortgage rate is priced off the score. On a $200,000 mortgage over 30 years, 7.0% costs $1,330.60 a month and $279,018 of total interest. At 6.5% it costs $1,264.14 a month and $255,089 of interest — $66.46 a month less, $798 a year less, $23,929 less over the life of the loan. Even a quarter-point improvement, 7.0% to 6.75%, saves about $33 a month.

So order A does two things the other orders do not: it clears the card interest in 25 months, and it arrives at the mortgage application with the utilization at zero and the score at its best. Order C arrives at the application with the card still at a high balance and the score still suppressed, and pays the higher mortgage rate for thirty years on top of the $5,394 of card interest. The mortgage-rate effect is larger than the card interest itself, and it is the part the "save first" plan never prices.

When save-first is still right

There are two cases where the order flips. The first is the emergency fund. If you have no cash buffer at all, the earlier emergency-fund post priced it: keep $500 to $1,000 in cash first, then attack the card. A broken car with no buffer goes straight back onto the card at 18.9%, and the whole plan restarts. The buffer is not savings for the house; it is insurance for the plan.

The second is a deadline. If the house purchase has a fixed date — a lease ending, a relocation, a rate lock — and the down payment must be ready by then, the schedule may force saving first. That is a constraint, not a preference, and it should be priced as one: saving first while the card runs on minimums costs $4,504 of extra card interest plus whatever the suppressed score adds to the mortgage rate. If the deadline is real, pay it knowingly. If it is only impatience, the card-first order is cheaper by every measure in this post.

What does not flip the order is the down payment target itself. A larger target makes the card-first advantage bigger, not smaller, because the card interest accrues while the longer savings period runs. A smaller target — say $10,000 instead of $20,000 — shortens the savings leg to about 46 months at $200 a month, and the card-first total becomes 25 plus 46, or 71 months, against a split total that is still dragged by the 67-month card payoff. The gap narrows; it does not reverse.

The honest notes

  • The payoff baseline is the same as the rest of this series: $4,100 at 18.9%, $200 a month, 25 months, $890 of interest; $130 a month takes 44 months and $1,612. The minimum-payment figures, 202 months and $5,394, are from the earlier minimum-payment post.
  • The savings figures assume a steady 4.5% APY and $200 or $100 a month, no withdrawals, no rate changes. Savings rates move; the direction of the comparison does not, as long as the savings rate stays far below 18.9%.
  • The mortgage figures are for a $200,000 loan over 30 years at the stated fixed rates. Your loan size, term and the rate your score actually earns will differ. The score-to-rate link is real but not mechanical — a better score improves the rate you are offered, it does not guarantee a specific number.
  • The $7,600 savings balance at month 67 in the split order is an approximation at 4.5% on $100 a month.
  • This is arithmetic on one example, not advice.

Run your own numbers

Try the baseline on the free calculator: https://alapha888.github.io/irregular-income-debt-baseline/

Top comments (0)