DEV Community

Andy Stanly
Andy Stanly

Posted on Edited on

Choosing a Bible Study Method by the Question You Are Asking

People tend to pick a Bible study method the way they pick a diet, by finding one that sounds appealing and then trying to live with it. That works badly, because almost every method is built to answer a specific question, and if your question is different, the method will feel strangely unsatisfying even when you are doing it correctly.

The observational method answers what is actually there. It is slow and it produces notes rather than answers, which is exactly right when you are reading something unfamiliar and want to see its shape before you interpret it. If your question is 'what does this actually say', this is the method. If your question is 'what does this mean for me', it will feel like a delay you did not ask for.

Most methods answer questions you did not ask

The inductive method is the mirror image. It starts from what you can see and works toward meaning, and it is the right tool when a passage is confusing and you have opinions you suspect are wrong. Its weakness is that it needs you to resist the move that makes it fail, which is jumping to the conclusion you arrived with.

The topical method answers a question you bring from outside the text. It is the right tool when you have a situation and want to find what the Bible says about it, and its weakness is that the topic defines the boundaries of what you will find. If the topic is anxiety, you will find comfort about anxiety, and you may never read the passages that argue with it.

The comparison method answers questions about differences: between two passages, between two testaments, between what a text says and what it seems to say. It is the most underused of the four and the most useful when you are close to a wrong conclusion. A side-by-side of the Bible study methods compared here is worth reading before you commit, because the choice of method is doing more work than most people assume.

More on this: Bible study methods comparison.

Top comments (0)