Metal injection moulding is often sold as the cheap version of CNC machining. It is not. It is a different trade: you buy shape freedom, and you pay in tolerance. Whether it wins on cost depends on three lines, and they should be checked one by one, not blended into a single quote.
The first line is weight. The sweet spot is 5-20 grams per part. Above roughly 50 grams, the debinding step - where the binder that holds the metal powder together is burned out - starts to let the green part sag, and the scrap rate eats the savings. The second line is shape. MIM moulds like injection moulding: angled holes, internal recesses, curved undercuts come out in one shot. A plain block with two machined faces gives MIM nothing to show off, and CNC - with zero tooling cost - wins immediately. The third line is volume. Tooling for MIM costs what an injection mould costs. Divide that by annual quantity and 5000 pieces per year is the practical break-even; below it, amortisation alone pushes the unit price back to CNC territory.
Before the three lines, there is a shortlist of parts MIM simply cannot do. Walls thinner than 0.3mm will not fill with feedstock. Parts over 50 grams sag. A mirror appearance cannot come out of the sintering furnace - the as-sintered surface is microscopically rough, so a mirror requirement silently converts the project into "MIM blank plus machining", and the cost advantage disappears.
Tolerance follows the same logic. The normal band is 0.3-0.5% of nominal size, which is fine for hinges, clips, small brackets, and lock parts. If a fit surface needs 0.05mm, leave 0.2mm of stock and machine that face after sintering; the straightening operation that fixes sinter shrinkage already puts a press fixture in place, so the extra machining is cheaper than it sounds.
The quote itself hides three lines that are easy to miss: post-processing charged per piece (straightening, deburring, plating), the scrap risk that rises with weight, and the fact that switching powder alloy means recalculating shrinkage and often redoing tooling. Count the side-cores on the drawing before you negotiate - reducing parting complexity saves more than arguing about the unit price. One small stainless part we handled dropped from 3.8 to 2.9 yuan per piece not by changing suppliers, but by changing the direction of one angled hole so it needed no side-core at all.
Top comments (0)