An SVG can contain one broken gradient reference before an edit and one after. It can also render exactly the same. To tell whether the edit introduced a new problem, compare the references themselves.
We tested this with a folder icon and a circular badge. The requested change was simple: turn the badge outline blue using Codex and the IconVectors MCP server.
Start with a defect you can identify
The folder in our test SVG used this paint value:
fill="url(#folderGradient) #F3C467"
The file had no element with the ID folderGradient. The yellow fallback, #F3C467, kept the folder visible in Edge. We recorded the defect as a tuple of the element ID, the attribute and the unresolved target ID:
(folder, fill, folderGradient)
Use an open-and-save control
We started both runs from fresh copies of the original SVG. Both used IconVectors 2.20 and the same open and save operations and settings.
- Control: Open the file and save a copy.
-
Edit: Open the file, find the
badgeelement by ID, set itsstroketo#2563EB, and save a copy.
The control still had the missing folder gradient. Ordinary saving rewrote the folder path’s quadratic curves as cubic curves. Edge produced the same pixels for the original and the control at 128 × 128 on a white background.
The edit preserved that same missing reference. Relative to the control, only the badge’s stroke color changed, from #303840 to #2563EB. Its fill, geometry and stroke width stayed the same.
| Comparison | Different pixels |
|---|---|
| Original vs. open-and-save control | 0 |
| Open-and-save control vs. MCP edit | 788 |
| Control recolored by hand vs. MCP edit | 0 |
The manually recolored control tells us that the 788 changed pixels are consistent with the requested edit. We repeated each IconVectors run with a fresh input and got byte-identical outputs within each pair of runs.
Why comparing counts misses a regression
We constructed a second example by hand. We set the folder’s fill to its solid fallback and changed the badge fill to url(#badgeGradient) #FAFAF7, leaving badgeGradient undefined.
| File | Element | Attribute | Missing target |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original | folder |
fill |
folderGradient |
| Hand-built example | badge |
fill |
badgeGradient |
Each file has one unresolved reference, and the two Edge renders are identical at the tested size. Both fallbacks match the colors already visible in the original. Comparing the tuples reveals exactly what changed:
Resolved: (folder, fill, folderGradient)
Introduced: (badge, fill, badgeGradient)
What to check after your next edit
- Open and save a control copy if your editor may rewrite SVG markup.
- Record each unresolved reference by element, attribute and target ID before and after the edit.
- Compare the added and removed references independently. For a targeted visual edit, compare the rendered output with a copy that contains only the intended change.
In this test, the MCP edit left the existing reference defect in place and produced the intended recolor. The hand-built example shows how an unchanged error count and an unchanged image can still conceal a new broken reference.
Top comments (0)