re: Is Uncle Bob serious? VIEW POST

re: Blaine, I think your article is interesting, yet it is built on a straw man fallacy. Robert Martin is not saying that NASA is not (or was not) doin...

Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment, Pierre.

I think I made a pretty convincing case that software complexity in safety critical systems can exceed our ability to comprehend it.

I quoted a safety critical systems expert with a PhD who said the same thing (two experts actually). And I quoted a section of Mr Martin's blog post where he lays all the blame for the problems described in the Atlantic article on the programmers.

I don't believe I setup a straw man argument. It's a pretty simple disagreement but as you can see from the multitude of comments here that there are no simple solutions.


code of conduct - report abuse