DEV Community

Cover image for Cathay Cargo alternative, Lufthansa Cargo alternatives, Forto alternatives: what actually changes on the air waybill

Cathay Cargo alternative, Lufthansa Cargo alternatives, Forto alternatives: what actually changes on the air waybill

Three searches that look alike and are not. Two of the names are airlines. The third is a forwarder that buys their space. Comparing all three on the per-kilo figure is where most of these evaluations go wrong — and the figure that decides the invoice sits one line below it.

A quote comes back higher than last quarter, or a shipment slips a day, and the first move is to search for an alternative. The search returns a list of names with a rate beside each one. The list mixes two different businesses, and the rate beside each name is not the rate anyone would be billed.

What each of them is, and what the published record does and does not contain, comes first.

Three names, two layers

Cathay Cargo is the freighter arm of Cathay Pacific, a oneworld member based at Hong Kong (HKG). It sells dedicated freighter capacity and belly space on passenger flights, so two quotes for the same airport pair can differ in cutoff time and capacity. Which product was booked is rarely visible on the quotation.

Lufthansa Cargo is the Lufthansa Group's freighter airline at Frankfurt (FRA) and a Star Alliance member. Its own 777F freighters are what most shippers mean, and it also sells belly space.

Forto is a digital freight platform in Berlin, recorded as independent private and venture-backed since 2022. It owns no aircraft. It buys space from carriers and resells it under a service contract, which puts it on the other side of the counter from the two airlines above.

An airline alternative changes who operates the flight. A forwarder alternative changes who is responsible for the booking, documents and contract — the flight underneath may not change at all.

All three have one thing in common: none publishes a per-kilo rate table by lane, and none publishes a schedule reliability figure. Only five carriers publish a reliability number at all, on a vessel basis, and none of the three is among them. A missing figure is not a verdict.

The line that decides the invoice before price is discussed

Air freight is billed on chargeable weight: the greater of actual weight and volumetric weight. The volumetric figure comes from dividing the carton's volume in cubic centimetres by a divisor, and there are two divisors in common use — 6,000 and 5,000. At 6,000, one cubic metre is 167 chargeable kilos. At 5,000, it is 200.

The same 12 kg carton, 60 by 40 by 40 centimetres, is 0.096 cubic metres. At a 6,000 divisor it bills as 16.0 kg. At 5,000 it bills as 19.2 kg. Nothing about the cargo changed; the bill moved 20 percent. On the Incheon–Frankfurt anchor of USD 5.19/kg, that is USD 83.04 against USD 99.65 for one carton, and about USD 620 on a shipment billed at 600 kg — before fuel and security surcharges, added on the same per-kilo basis.

Same carton, two volumetric divisors: 16.0 kg against 19.2 kg chargeable weight (BtoB-GoGo; freight anchor TAC Index, 6 November 2026)

So the first question is not the rate. It is which divisor applies, how volumetric weight is rounded, and whether both quotes were built on the same basis. A quote at 5,000 against one at 6,000 is not cheaper; it is a different product.

The benchmark, and the width of the band around it

What is published sits one level below the airline: corridor benchmarks anchored to the TAC Index, dated 6 November 2026, each with a range.

Shanghai Pudong to Frankfurt was USD 5.31 per kg (range 3.45–7.17), Incheon to Frankfurt 5.19 (3.37–7.01), Tokyo Narita to London Heathrow 5.56 (3.61–7.51), Hong Kong to Chicago 7.64 (4.97–10.31) and Incheon to New York JFK 7.80 (5.07–10.53). All five are airport to airport, 1 to 2 days, freight line only.

Five air benchmarks with the plus or minus 35 percent band, TAC Index, 6 November 2026

The band is plus or minus 35 percent: the honest width of a reference value that is not a booking rate. Two quotations on Incheon–Frankfurt — one at USD 3.37, one at USD 7.01 — both sit inside it. The gap is usually product, not overcharging: belly with a connection against a direct freighter, spot against contract, peak week against a quiet one.

That is why a rate comparison between the two airlines and a forwarder's quote rarely concludes: the benchmark is a freight-line reference, the invoice a stack of freight, fuel and security surcharges, terminal handling at both ends, AWB and documentation, and on some lanes a capacity surcharge. Ask for each as its own line: a lump sum cannot be compared.

An alternative in the same alliance is often the same flight

Once the shortlist exists, the first screen is alliance and parent, not price. Airlines in one grouping share schedules and space, so switching can put the cargo on the same metal with a different letterhead.

Cathay Cargo is in oneworld, and every same-mode candidate the directory lists beside it sits outside that alliance: ANA Cargo and Asiana Cargo in Star Alliance, China Airlines Cargo in SkyTeam, China Cargo Airlines under China Eastern Group, AirZeta (formerly Air Incheon) under Socius PE with no alliance — none shares Cathay's schedules by default.

Lufthansa Cargo is a different case. Of its five listed candidates, Turkish Cargo is a Star Alliance member, and AeroLogic is a DHL and Lufthansa joint venture — the same parent, in a different livery. Both are weak substitutes for what the shipper is trying to escape. DHL Aviation, IAG Cargo and ACT Airlines sit outside the group.

Candidates for Cathay Cargo and Lufthansa Cargo, sorted by alliance and parent

The line also moves: Asiana Cargo is recorded as a Star Alliance member that exits on 16 December 2026, so a shortlist written this month is not the one to use next quarter. Confirm the operating carrier on the schedule, not the marketing carrier on the quote.

Forto alternatives are a different question

Because Forto buys space rather than operating it, a Forto alternative changes the service layer: customs brokerage, oversized and project cargo, contract rates on high-volume lanes, and the terms in the bill of lading. The airline underneath may be identical.

Forto publishes no tariff with free time and overrun rates, and neither do the forwarders it is listed against — Scan Global Logistics (majority-owned by CVC Capital Partners), CEVA Logistics (CMA CGM Group), DB Schenker (DSV Group since April 2025), DHL Global Forwarding and DSV Air & Sea. Free time and detention terms live in the service contract per bill of lading — the right place for them, and useless for comparison until there is a booking in hand.

For that layer the comparison is not a rate at all. It is one all-in quotation per shipment, same lane, same week, split into freight, terminal handling, surcharges and free time, with the clock's start point named. Digital platforms tend to be stronger on instant quotes and API tracking; traditional 3PLs on customs and project cargo. Nothing published supports a general answer on which is cheaper.

Air against ocean, in one number

For anything heavy and not urgent, mode comes before carrier. Incheon to Frankfurt by air is USD 5.19 per kg, 1 to 2 days. Busan to Rotterdam by sea is USD 0.18 per kg — USD 3,513 per 40ft container, converted at an assumed 20,000 kg of cargo — and 32 to 38 days. Air costs about 30 times as much per kilo and arrives about 34 days sooner.

That is an order of magnitude, not a quotation. It frames the decision the right way: what a day of transit is worth on this consignment, not which rate is lower. Once the answer is air, the divisor, the alliance and the surcharge lines decide the rest.

Five lines to ask each of them

  1. The volumetric divisor, and how volumetric weight is rounded.
  2. Fuel and security surcharges as separate per-kilo lines, with the rate and its validity period.
  3. Terminal handling at origin and destination, in the currency charged, with the effective date.
  4. Direct freighter or belly sector with a connection, and which airline operates the second sector.
  5. Total transit in days, the cargo cutoff at origin, and how long the quote holds.

Where the figures come from

Every number here was read on 19 November 2026 from the carrier, lane and comparison pages of BtoB-GoGo, published by MMS Consulting Group, Siheung, Korea. Benchmark values are dated 6 November 2026; carrier and terminal tariff checks are dated 15 November 2026.

The directory holds 100 corridor benchmarks (86 ocean, 7 air, 7 rail), 150 company profiles (51 ocean carriers, 42 air, 38 forwarders and 3PLs, 19 rail) and 370 comparisons. Each figure carries a basis grade and an error band: from plus or minus 10 percent on published index lanes to 50 percent on model estimates, with the TAC-scaled air lanes at 35. What could not be verified is filed as a gap rather than filled in.

None of it is a rate anyone can book. The publisher takes no booking commission; the contract stays with whoever issues the air waybill.


Check the figures yourself

Top comments (0)