The email that starts this search never says "alternatives". It says something like: the line is down, 240 kg of a part that weighs nothing and costs everything has to be in Chicago on Thursday, and the forwarder has come back with one option and one price. At that point you are not shopping for a cheaper airline. You are trying to find out whether a second airline can physically take the shipment in the window you have, and what it will add to the number when it does. That is a different question from the one most "alternatives" pages answer, and the difference is where the money is. If you have ever accepted a single quote at 2am because there was no time to build a second one, this post is written for that night.
Everything below is from the free public pages at BtoB-GoGo (benchmarks as of 6 November 2026) and from the airlines' own publications, checked on 21 November 2026. Where a figure does not exist publicly — and in air freight most of them do not — it is named as missing rather than filled in.
What the per-kg number is, and is not
Lufthansa Cargo does not publish a per-kg tariff by lane, and neither does any other airline. What its directory page carries instead is the corridor benchmark anchored to the TAC Index: $5.31 per kg on Shanghai (Pudong) → Frankfurt, stated range $3.45–$7.17, transit 1–2 days, basis grade A (±35%, scaled from the TAC Index). That is a market reference, not a quotation. A real quote adds fuel and security surcharges per kg, terminal handling at both airports, AWB and ULD build per shipment, and it is built on chargeable weight.
The chart is the first useful thing to see before ranking anything, and it is uncomfortable. Six lanes, same week, same basis grade:
| Lane | Benchmark | Stated range | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Incheon → Frankfurt | $5.19 | $3.37–$7.01 | A ±35% |
| Shanghai (PVG) → Frankfurt | $5.31 | $3.45–$7.17 | A ±35% |
| Tokyo (Narita) → London (Heathrow) | $5.56 | $3.61–$7.51 | A ±35% |
| Incheon → Chicago (ORD) | $7.48 | $4.86–$10.10 | A ±35% |
| Hong Kong → Chicago | $7.64 | $4.97–$10.31 | A ±35% |
| Incheon → New York (JFK) | $7.80 | $5.07–$10.53 | A ±35% |
Two facts follow, and both change how an "alternatives" decision should be run.
First, the lanes separate; the carriers do not. Europe lanes sit at $5.19–$5.56 per kg and North American lanes at $7.48–$7.80 — a 40–50% difference created by direction and destination, not by who flies it. Against that, every band is ±35%. A quote of $7.10/kg on Incheon → Frankfurt is inside the stated range; so is $3.60. An alternatives comparison built on a per-kg figure therefore cannot tell you which airline is cheaper, because the measurement is too wide to contain the difference. It can tell you one thing: when a quote arrives outside the band entirely, that is information about the routing or the surcharges, not about the market.
Second, ±35% is not a defect, it is the honest width. Grade A means "air, scaled from the TAC Index", and the width is what a scaled index admits. A ±10% number on an air lane would be a manufactured precision. Treat the band as the range inside which a quote is unremarkable, and spend the effort where the variables actually are.
The alternative that cannot be bought
The directory lists AeroLogic as a same-mode alternative to Lufthansa Cargo, and that is technically right: it is a German cargo airline flying 28 Boeing 777 freighters out of Leipzig/Halle and Frankfurt. It is also, per its own corporate page and its shareholders' publications, a 50/50 joint venture of DHL Express and Lufthansa Cargo, founded in 2007–08, with no sales organisation of its own: the capacity is marketed by the two shareholders' sales teams, and each flight is operated for one of them.
That makes AeroLogic a real distinction and a useless shopping option at the same time. You cannot put a rate request to AeroLogic and compare it with a rate request to Lufthansa Cargo, because both requests land in one of two sales organisations that share the same aircraft. Profile: AeroLogic alternatives 2026. When a capacity crunch is real, this shared capacity is exactly the thing that is not available — which is worth knowing before you count two airlines as two independent options.
The same test applies to every airline name you collect: ask whose aircraft and whose AWB. A carrier that sells space on another carrier's freighter is a commercial alternative, not an operational one.
The alternative the calendar is about to change
The page for Cathay Cargo lists ANA Cargo, Asiana Cargo, China Airlines Cargo and China Cargo Airlines as same-mode candidates. One line in that list has a date on it that matters for time-critical work: Asiana Cargo is recorded as a Star Alliance member until it leaves the alliance on 16 December 2026 at 23:59 KST, ahead of its integration with Korean Air.
That is not a footnote. Alliance membership is how space, connections and handling are shared between airlines, so a set of "alternatives" assembled on alliance lines in November will mean something different in January. If your routing depends on an interline or a connection inside an alliance, check the date on the membership, not just the name. Asiana's own notice and Lufthansa Group's newsroom both state the date; the directory carries it as a field so it can be seen before it bites.
The other three names in that list — ANA Cargo, China Airlines Cargo and China Cargo Airlines — are worth a request for a different reason: each is anchored at a different hub (Tokyo, Taipei, Shanghai), so on a time-critical shipment the hub is the product, not the airline.
You pay for the space, not the weight
This is the single most useful arithmetic in air freight, and it is the one most often missed when a quote is compared on price per kilo alone. The chargeable weight is the greater of actual and volumetric weight, at the industry divisor of 6,000 cm³ per kg — 1 CBM ≈ 167 kg.
A 2 CBM shipment at 100 kg/m³ weighs 200 kg and is billed at 334 kg. At 60 kg/m³ it weighs 120 kg and is billed at the same 334 kg. Below a density of about 167 kg/m³, the kilos you are buying are air, and no amount of airline selection changes that — only repacking, a different unit, or a different mode does.
That is also the honest limit of a per-kg benchmark: it prices a kilo, and your shipment's cost is set by the density of what you put in the box. Which is why the most valuable "alternative" in a time-critical shipment is frequently not another airline but a decision about the packing.
What actually decides a time-critical shipment
Freight rate ranks about fifth. These are the lines to get in writing, in this order:
- Latest cut-off, with the time zone named, and whether the shipment is accepted at the terminal or only at the airline's cargo facility.
- Flight frequency on the lane and whether the routing is direct. A daily non-stop and a twice-weekly with a hub transit are different products at the same per-kg rate.
- Whether the space is an allotment or ad hoc. Blocked space survives a peak; ad hoc space is where a shipment goes missing at the worst moment.
- Surcharges per kg with the validity date — fuel and security are revised monthly, so a quote without a date is not a quote.
- The per-kg benchmark band (the table above) as a sanity check, not as a target.
- Chargeable weight basis and who measures the cargo.
- Terminal handling at origin, transit and destination, itemised.
- Door-to-airport or door-to-door, and who does the trucking at each end — the 1–2 day transit in the band is airport to airport.
- Who is accountable when a connection is missed, and on which document the liability sits.
Nine answers, one email per candidate, same shipment details. That is what makes two quotes comparable; without it you are choosing between two totals that hide different unknowns.
What this cannot tell you
It cannot tell you which airline is punctual. No airline in the directory publishes a schedule reliability figure — only five companies in the 150-company set do, all ocean carriers, monthly and per vessel. It cannot tell you the space available on your date, and it will not estimate a surcharge. Those are sales conversations and system lookups, and a blog post that supplies them has invented them.
The benchmark values, ranges and basis grades above are from the free corridor pages on BtoB-GoGo, compiled by MMS Consulting Group, Korea, published with their error band and their basis grade rather than as prices. AeroLogic's ownership and fleet come from its own corporate pages and its shareholders' published reporting; the Asiana date from the airline's own customer notice and Lufthansa Group's newsroom. The full dossier — the source mapping and the underlying tariff-day tables behind each benchmark — is proprietary and is not reproduced here. Every number in this post can be checked on the free pages. Questions about a specific figure, or the source behind it, go to saasradar.sponsor@gmail.com.


Top comments (0)