Ask three Asian forwarders for the same Busan box and you get three all-in numbers that look comparable. They are not, and the reason is not the price: it is that none of the three publishes any of the four figures that decide the invoice. What they do publish is a parent group, a headquarters, and a mode — and on a Korea–Japan–Southeast Asia corridor, that is enough to tell you which two quotes are worth spending time on and which are a phone call repeated.
This post uses three companies that a Korea-based shipper meets constantly: Nippon Express (NX), Yusen Logistics and CJ Logistics. Every figure below comes from their public records on BtoB-GoGo, checked on 20 November 2026, plus the published carrier tariff tables on the same site. No estimates are invented for the gaps — the gaps are the subject.
Seven lines you can check before you call
This is the part that takes two minutes and saves a week:
| field | Nippon Express (NX) | Yusen Logistics | CJ Logistics |
|---|---|---|---|
| parent group | NX Group | NYK Group | CJ Group |
| headquarters | Tokyo, Japan | Tokyo, Japan | Seoul, South Korea |
| mode recorded | 3PL / Forwarder | 3PL / Forwarder | 3PL / Express |
| free time published | no | no | no |
| demurrage ladder published | no | no | no |
| schedule reliability published | no | no | no |
| own tariff published | no | no | no |
Two of the three are Japanese and one is Korean, which is exactly the shape of the corridor. It also produces the first useful observation: both Japanese records point at the same three alternatives — CJ Logistics, Hyundai Glovis, Kerry Logistics. A shortlist assembled from those two pages therefore tends to collapse into a handful of names from two networks, which is worth knowing before you treat three replies as three independent bids.
# what the directory carries for each of the three
free_time_tariff_published: false # 4 of 150 companies publish a ladder
schedule_reliability_published: null # 5 of 150 publish reliability, all carriers
own_tariff_published: false
ownership_status: checked_against_public_sources
That null is the honest representation, not a missing value to be filled with a guess. Schedule reliability is published monthly, per vessel, by five ocean carriers. A forwarder-level punctuality ranking is therefore not "not yet available" but structurally impossible from public data — for these three, and for everyone else.
Free time and the two clocks
If you are shipping out of Busan, the Korean side of the invoice is unusually well documented, and it is the only half you can check without asking anyone. On Korea import, dry 20'/40', four carriers print a full ladder in KRW per day:
Maersk 10 free days -> 11-15 d 30,000 -> 16-20 d 50,000 -> 21+ d 90,000
Hapag-Lloyd 10 free days -> 1-5 d 30,000 -> 6-10 d 50,000 -> 11+ d 90,000
OOCL 12 free days -> 1-7 d 30,000 -> 8-14 d 50,000 -> 15+ d 85,000
COSCO 12 free days -> 13-19 d 30,000 -> 20-26 d 50,000 -> 27+ d 60,000
By day 14, Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd are at KRW 120,000 a container and OOCL and COSCO at KRW 60,000. By day 21 it is KRW 490,000 against KRW 310,000. None of the three forwarders prints a ladder of its own: their free time lives in the service contract and on the B/L. So this published table is not their price — it is the floor of what you will be charged, if the slot under your quotation was bought from one of those four.
The second clock is shorter. Terminal storage on Korea import is 4 days in Busan (PNC, BPT, BNCT, PNIT, BCT), 7 in Incheon (ICT, SNCT) and 14 in Gwangyang (GWCT). On a Busan import with a Maersk B/L, the terminal starts charging on day 5 and the carrier on day 11: for six days, storage is billing while demurrage is not. That is why a forwarder's "free time" answer can be technically true and still leave you paying.
There is one more asymmetry worth writing into the contract. On Korea, all four carriers give 14 free days on export against 10 or 12 on import. A quotation that says "free time as per carrier tariff" without naming the direction has not said which table it used.
The four numbers, and why the holes matter
Put the three records next to the carrier table and the structure of the problem is clear:
- Free time: published by 4 of the 150 companies in the directory, none of them forwarders.
- Demurrage ladder: same four, all ocean carriers.
- Terminal storage: published by terminal operators, invoiced separately from demurrage.
- Schedule reliability: 5 of 150, all carriers, monthly, per vessel.
A forwarder can tell you what it will charge for the ocean leg and the handling. It cannot tell you, from a public page, what a late pickup will cost, because that number is created by the carrier and the terminal and then passed through a contract. So the useful question is not "what is your free time" — it is "which carrier tariff does your free time follow, and in which direction".
The seven lines to send, once
One email, all three forwarders, same shipment details. This is the whole method:
- Free time on this shipment, in writing, and the day the clock starts (discharge or gate-out).
- Demurrage and detention as separate numbers, with the tier days spelled out.
- Whether terminal storage is included or passed through, and at which terminal.
- THC at both ends, per container size, with the tariff effective date — Busan 40ft is KRW 240,000 from 2026-07-01.
- Carbon and fuel surcharges named as lines, not folded into the freight.
- Who issues the B/L, and which legal entity signs the contract.
- The same validity date on every quotation you compare.
With seven answers, three quotes become comparable in an afternoon. Without them you are comparing three totals that each hide a different set of unknowns — which is how a corridor with three good forwarders ends up being decided by whichever number arrived first.
What this cannot tell you
It cannot rank the three. None publishes a reliability figure, and the directory does not record which lanes each serves at what volume — that is a sales conversation. It also cannot tell you that the Korean-owned forwarder is better on Korea, or that the Japanese ones are better on Japan; the records say nothing of the kind, and filling that gap with intuition is how the corridor got its reputation for opaque pricing in the first place.
The figures are checked against the 150-company directory and the published carrier tariff tables on BtoB-GoGo up to 20 November 2026, and compiled by MMS Consulting Group. The Busan → Rotterdam lane is a good place to see how a reference, its error band and the free-time ladder sit on one page. Questions about the data set, or the original source behind a specific number, go to saasradar.sponsor@gmail.com.


Top comments (0)