DEV Community

Dev Station
Dev Station

Posted on

Sort your defects before you buy an automated inspection system

Three families of automated inspection: vision, metrology and functional test

An automated inspection system is any setup of sensors, fixtures and software that judges a part against a spec with no person deciding each case. Search results treat the term as a synonym for machine vision. A leak tester, a coordinate measuring machine (CMM) and a bed of nails on a circuit board are all automated inspection too, and none of them uses a camera.

We wrote the longer version on our blog, Automated Inspection Systems: Three Families, Not One. This post is the part an engineer can run on a real line this week: classify the defects first.

The three families

Each family is defined by what it physically measures.

  • Vision: appearance and presence. Surface marks, missing components, print, orientation, colour. Fast and non contact, so it usually runs inline.
  • Metrology: geometry to a stated uncertainty. CMMs, laser scanners, air gauges. Slow, usually sampled offline, traceable to a standard.
  • Functional test: behaviour. Leak decay, continuity, torque to turn, pressure hold. The result is a number from the part itself.

A defect list you can actually scope from

Pull defects from reject records. Memory is a bad source. Then tag each row:

- defect: scratch on cover
  type: appearance      # vision
  coverage: every_part
- defect: bore out of tolerance
  type: dimension       # metrology
  coverage: sample
- defect: housing leaks
  type: behaviour       # functional test
  coverage: every_part
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Coverage is its own column because it moves the budget more than the sensor does. A CMM cannot keep up with a fast line, which is why metrology is usually sampled and vision is usually inline.

Checklist before any supplier demo

  • [ ] Every defect tagged appearance, dimension or behaviour
  • [ ] Coverage decided per defect, every part or a sample
  • [ ] Acceptance test written: recall and precision per defect, on parts from a different shift
  • [ ] Presentation priced: fixture, lighting, guarding, controls, changeover
  • [ ] A destination agreed for results, since a pass or fail that stays in the machine helps nobody at the next audit

Two families on one line is normal. A pump housing might get inline vision for assembly, a leak test on every unit and a sampled CMM check on the critical bore.

Watch for defects that sit between families. Surface porosity that only matters because it leaks is a behaviour problem in a visual disguise, and the leak test settles it faster.

Dev Station builds the record layer around these stations: result store, operator review screen, gauge integration over Bluetooth or serial. The full breakdown of families, coverage and cost is in the original article.

Top comments (0)