DEV Community

dragonair
dragonair

Posted on Edited on Originally published at 6sq.com

Gage R&R in five minutes without opening Excel

Most Gage R&R arguments are not about the math. They are about the study design: parts that do not span the tolerance, operators who can see the previous reading, and a report where the %GRR number was computed against the process variation while the drawing calls out a tolerance.

Here is a routine that survives an audit.

1. Design first

  • 10 parts, chosen to span the specification — deliberately including good and bad ones. Ten parts from one hour of production span almost nothing, and a gauge always looks brilliant when the parts are identical.
  • 3 operators, the ones who actually run the gauge on the floor.
  • 3 trials each, randomised. Parts re-presented in a different order every round, identification hidden.
  • 10 × 3 × 3 = 90 readings. Yes, it is tedious. A 5 × 2 × 2 study (20 readings) produces a confidence interval so wide it cannot distinguish a good gauge from a marginal one.

The design has to be blind: if the operator can see the value from the previous trial, you are measuring their memory, not the gauge.

2. Two numbers, one denominator

%GRR is a ratio, and the question is what it is a ratio of:

%EV  = 100 * (repeatability)      / denominator
%AV  = 100 * (reproducibility)    / denominator
%GRR = 100 * sqrt(EV^2 + AV^2)    / denominator
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

The two acceptable denominators:

Denomintor Use when Typical threshold
Tolerance (USL − LSL) The part is judged against a spec limit under 10% good, 10–30% marginal
6 × process sigma You are studying the measurement system on its own same bands, different meaning

Pick one and state it in the report. A gauge that is 8% of tolerance but 28% of process variation is a real and common situation — and it is not a contradiction, it is two different questions. The gauge can be fine for sorting parts and useless for SPC, because SPC needs to see variation the gauge is currently hiding.

3. Number of distinct categories

ndc = 1.41 * (part variation / GRR variation)
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Under 5 means the gauge cannot resolve the process into enough levels to be useful for control charts, no matter what %GRR says. This is the number that catches "good %GRR, useless gauge" cases.

4. The three mistakes that invalidate the study

Parts do not span the process. If part-to-part variation is tiny, GRR/part-variation explodes and %GRR looks terrible for a perfectly good gauge. Fix the part selection before you fix the gauge.

Operators are trained during the study. A study run right after a refresher measures a trained state that will not exist next month. Run it cold.

Reading order is not randomised. Drift, warm-up, and fixture wear all masquerade as reproducibility.

5. What to do with a marginal result (10–30%)

Do not immediately buy a new gauge. In order:

  1. Check the fixture and the clamping method — most repeatability problems are seating problems.
  2. Check whether the operators use the gauge the same way (same datum, same force, same number of readings averaged).
  3. Only then consider gauge capability itself.

A gauge that is 15% of tolerance with the fixture fixed is usually 22% with it broken.

Doing it without a spreadsheet

I keep a browser calculator for exactly this loop — Gage R&R / MSA — paste the 90 readings, get %EV, %AV, %GRR, ndc, and the by-operator breakdown. No signup and the numbers never leave the tab, which matters when the readings are a customer's parts.

Disclosure: I maintain 6SQ Tools, free browser-based quality calculators. The thresholds above follow the AIAG MSA reference manual (4th ed.); the routine is what I use before trusting any capability number downstream of the gauge.

Top comments (0)