DEV Community

Jan S.
Jan S.

Posted on

How I Choose Which Keywords to Work on First

Keyword research can get messy pretty quickly.

You start with a few ideas, check what your competitors are ranking for, and before you know it, you have hundreds of keywords in a spreadsheet.

The problem is, you can't write about all of them. And not every keyword is worth your time.

So how do you decide where to start?

Here's a simple way to sort through the list.

First, remove keywords that don't fit

Just because people search for something doesn't mean it's a good topic for your website.

For example, if you run a website about project management software, a keyword about project management jobs probably won't bring the right visitors.

I'd first remove keywords that have little to do with the website or the people you're trying to reach.

This one step can make a big list much easier to work with.

Look at what people are searching for

Next, try to understand what someone wants when they search for a keyword.

Take these two examples:

  • "What is keyword research?"
  • "Best keyword research tools"

They are both about keyword research, but people searching for them want different things.

The first person wants an explanation. The second is probably looking at different tools.

This matters when planning content. You don't want to write a general guide when people are looking for a comparison.

A quick look at Google's search results can help you understand what kind of page people expect to see.

Check if you already have a page for it

Before writing a new article, check your existing pages.

Google Search Console is a good place to start. Look for keywords where your pages are already getting impressions but not many clicks.

You can also check pages that are ranking, but not as high as you'd like.

Sometimes, updating an existing article makes more sense than writing a new one.

For example, you might find an article that ranks around position 12 for a keyword you care about. Check whether the information is still useful, whether it answers the question, and what the other pages in the search results are doing.

There may be a chance to improve it.

Take a look at the other websites ranking

I wouldn't rely only on the keyword difficulty number from an SEO tool.

Open the search results and look at the pages that are already ranking.

Are they from big websites? Do they answer the question well? Is there something missing that you could explain better?

This gives you a better idea of what you're up against.

A keyword with a low difficulty score isn't automatically easy to rank for. It's worth checking the actual results before adding it to your list.

Give each keyword a simple score

You don't need a complicated system for this.

I would give each keyword a score from 1 to 5 based on four things:

What to check Question to ask
Relevance Does this topic fit my website?
Search volume Are people searching for it?
Competition Can my website compete with the current results?
Content opportunity Can I offer something useful that isn't already covered?

Add up the scores and use them to compare keywords.

For example, a keyword with fewer searches but a clear audience and weak search results might be a better choice than a broad keyword with thousands of searches.

The scores are just a guide. Don't let a spreadsheet make the decision for you.

Keep the shortlist small

Once you've checked the keywords, pick a few to work on first.

I find it more useful to give each keyword a next step instead of just keeping it in a list.

For example:

Keyword What to do
Keyword A Update an existing article
Keyword B Write a new article
Keyword C Check the search results again
Keyword D Leave it for later

This makes it easier to know what to do next.

You can always come back to the other keywords later.

Check what happens after publishing

Your work doesn't stop once an article is published.

Give it some time, then check Google Search Console to see if it's getting impressions and clicks. Look at which search terms are bringing people to the page.

If the page isn't doing well, try to understand why before making changes. Maybe the topic isn't what people are looking for, or perhaps another page is answering the question better.

You won't get every keyword choice right. That's part of the process.

The useful thing is to learn from each page and use that information when choosing your next topic.

I've also been looking at ways to make competitor and keyword research easier to review. It's something we're exploring with Inteldo's SEO Analyst, but the basic process is still the same: check the data, look at the actual search results, and choose topics that make sense for your website.

My biggest takeaway is that a long keyword list isn't much help on its own.

I'd rather have ten good keywords with a clear next step than hundreds of keywords I don't know what to do with.

Top comments (0)