DEV Community

OpenGMB
OpenGMB

Posted on

Asking for Google reviews without review gating: what a tool can and can't check

Most review-request tools are built to get more five-star reviews. The quickest way to do that is also against Google's rules: ask the happy customers for a review and send the unhappy ones somewhere else. That pattern is called review gating, and Google's review policy names selectively soliciting positive reviews as rating manipulation.

This post covers how review requests work in OpenGMB, the open-source Google Business Profile manager we build at Synectus, and the choices we made so that the easy path is also the compliant one.

Three ways to ask

Each location gets three routes:

  • An email campaign, with an optional reminder.
  • A short tracked link that opens Google's review form for that location.
  • A QR code that points to the same link, as an SVG, a PNG or a printable counter card (PDF) for the front desk.

OpenGMB does not send text messages. If you want to text the link, paste it into your own message and add a tag, so those clicks are counted separately.

The wording check

The part we care about most is the message itself. When you write a campaign, a wording check refuses a subject or message that asks for stars, a rating, a score, a survey or feedback, or that asks how the visit was.

So this email is blocked:

How was your visit? If you loved it, rate us 5 stars on Google.

and the editor says why: the email may only ask for a Google review, never for a rating, a score, a survey or how the visit went.

The same message and the same link go to everyone. There is no step that routes unhappy customers to a private feedback form instead.

Consent and unsubscribes

Before anyone is added, you confirm you have permission to email them. You can paste a CSV or add people one at a time, up to 500 per import. Every email has a one-click unsubscribe header and a footer link, and anyone who unsubscribes is skipped for that client from then on.

Timing and the reminder

A reminder goes out 1 to 14 days later (3 by default), and only to people who have not clicked. Mail goes out between 8 AM and 9 PM in the client's time zone, so nobody gets a review request at midnight.

What we deliberately don't track

OpenGMB counts clicks by source: link, QR code or email, plus your own tags. It does not track email opens, and it does not match a click to the review it led to. You see which route brings people to the review form, not a guess about who wrote what.

The website widget

One script tag adds your Google reviews to a website, as a grid, list, carousel or badge, and it shows at most 6 reviews. The widget is off until you turn it on. It can show every rating or only 4- and 5-star reviews, and when it filters, it says so on the widget. A healthcare client starts with the badge layout, which shows the rating and the review count with no review text.

What a tool can't check

A wording check can stop a gated email. It can't stop someone handing QR cards only to the customers who smiled at the counter. The rule is about how you ask, not just what the email says, so the habit that matters is simple: ask everyone, the same way.

The details and screenshots are on the OpenGMB review requests page. The community edition is MIT-licensed on GitHub at synectus/OpenGMB.

Disclosure: this post is from the OpenGMB team at Synectus.

Top comments (0)