DEV Community

RUNZEAI
RUNZEAI

Posted on Originally published at q1z2q3-debug.github.io

Hexagram 38, Kui: one eye in the character, two eyes in the meaning

睽。小事吉。

Hexagram 38 is about divergence, and its character contains a detail that its meaning contradicts.

睽 is 目不相聽

說文: 睽,目不相聽也。從目,癸聲.

Three layers:

  1. The shape: one eye, plus a sound.
  2. The gloss: 聽 in classical usage can mean "to follow, to go along with." 目不相聽 — two eyes that cannot go to the same place together.
  3. So: the character is drawn with a single eye, and the meaning is about two eyes disagreeing.

One eye, describing the failure of two to agree.

Which is a very precise emblem for divergence: the split is not between two things, it is between two views that cannot be brought into one line of sight.

小事吉

The judgement is only three characters: 睽,小事吉.

吉 is granted, with a 小 in front of it.

Which is the chapter's most important proportion: the 易 admits that a time of divergence has good fortune in it, and locates that good fortune in what is near and small.

So the hexagram's advice is not reconciliation at scale. It is: work the small things, and do not attempt the large ones.

喪馬勿逐,自復

初九: a horse is lost; do not chase it, it comes back on its own.

The image of estrangement that should not be pursued. And then: 見惡人,無咎 — see the person you do not get along with, and no fault.

Which is the most practical line in the chapter: do not chase the departed, and do not avoid the difficult. Both actions are attempts to control the distance, and the line refuses both.

遇主于巷

九二 遇主于巷,無咎.

巷: the lane inside the neighbourhood, opposed to 堂, the formal hall.

So the meeting with one's lord happens in a lane, not in the hall: unarranged, not ceremonial, not announced.

Which says something exact about how things get reconnected in a time of 睽: not through the proper channel, but through a passage that is nobody's official route.

輿曳 / 牛掣 / 天且劓

六三: the cart dragged backward, the ox checked, and the person branded on the forehead and deprived of the nose.

天 is 黥, branding the forehead; 劓 is cutting off the nose.

So: motion pulled back, the draft animal blocked, and the driver marked permanently.

The line is a three-part picture of being held while being punished for not moving.

And then: 无初有終 — no beginning, but an end. Which is the only consolation in it.

睽孤, twice

九四 and 上九 both open with 睽孤 — divergent and alone.

Nine-four: 遇元夫,交孚,厲無咎 — meets a good man (元 is good), trusts mutually, dangerous, no fault. The lone position finds one ally, and the danger does not go away; it is simply survivable.

Top line: 見豕負塗,載鬼一車,先張之弧,後說之弧 — a pig covered in mud, a cartload of ghosts, the bow drawn and then unbent.

Which the book marks as remarkable: 鬼 appears in the classic text of the 易 almost only here.

A pig in mud and a cart of ghosts are the ugly projections of suspicion — and then the bow is lowered. So the top of 睽 is the moment when the imagination has finished producing monsters and the weapon is put away, which the text treats as the end of the estrangement.

同而異

The 象: 君子以同而異.

Not "find what is common among differences" — the hedge. 同 itself has a boundary.

So the instruction is: agree, and allow the difference. Which is harder than either agreeing or dividing, and it is the only thing that closes the chapter.

The test

Take a relation that has drifted. Ask which line describes it: the horse not chased, the meeting in the lane, the cart held back, the ghost cart. The last one is the one to watch for — it means the estrangement has begun manufacturing evidence.

Where to read it

License: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.


Previous: hexagram 37, on a household and its two sounds. Next: hexagram 39, 蹇 — six lines that all contain the same character, and four that begin the same way.

Top comments (0)