DEV Community

RainbowSea
RainbowSea

Posted on

Don't Copy the Best-Seller. Copy the Second Product.

Every product research guide tells you to start with a store's best-seller. I did that for months, and it cost me more failed tests than anything else I tried.
Last spring I found a store selling a galaxy projector lamp. It was the best-seller by a mile: hundreds of reviews, a big "BEST SELLER" badge, ads all over my feed. I spent a weekend building a test around it — same product, a slightly better angle, cleaner photos. Two weeks and $180 in ads later, I had four sales. Then I did the check I should have done first. I searched for the same lamp and found forty stores selling the identical item with nearly identical ads. The best-seller wasn't a winning product. It was a traffic jam, and I'd driven straight into it.
That flop changed how I read a store. Now I scroll past the hero product and look at whatever sits in second place.
A few months later I was looking at a tiny pet-supplies store — the kind with a plain theme and no fancy branding. Its best-seller was a $6 squeaky toy with 900 reviews in three weeks, an obvious viral spike. But the second product was a $24 grooming brush with sixty reviews spread over eight months. No badge, no ads, just steady sales month after month. The toy was the bait. The brush was the business.
Here's the idea in one sentence: the best-seller shows you what a store can promote. The second product shows you what a store can actually sell, week after week, without a viral moment behind it.
If you want to try it, here are the three checks I run on a store's second product:

  1. Are the reviews spread out? A product with sixty reviews across eight months is a steadier signal than one with nine hundred reviews in three weeks. Clusters mean a spike. A spread means repeat demand.
  2. Does the store keep investing in it? Look for restocks, new variants, or a slightly better version of the same product. A store that keeps touching a product believes in it. A store that launched it once and never looked back was probably testing it and moved on.
  3. Does it solve a repeat problem? Grooming brushes, refills, replacements, accessories — things people buy again or buy alongside something else. One-time novelties make great best-sellers and terrible businesses. One warning: sometimes the second product is a spike too. If a store's top two products both launched in the same month and both have review clusters from the same three weeks, you're looking at a store that caught one wave, not a store with a system. The version of this test I trust most is a store where the second product predates the best-seller — the quiet product was there first, and the viral one came later. That order tells you the owner knew how to sell before they got lucky. None of this works if you're looking at stores everyone already knows about. By the time a store shows up in every research tool, its second product has been copied too. So I look at stores while they're still young. I find them on RainbowSea, which surfaces newly registered websites that are suddenly surging in traffic — if you want to discover trending new stores before the rest of the research crowd gets there, that's where I start. Then I go straight to the second product and run the three checks. The best-seller will always be louder. But the second product is where the store's real opinion lives — it's the thing the owner keeps selling after the viral moment fades. Copy that, and you're copying a business, not a spike. When was the last time a best-seller list steered you wrong — and what did the store's second product tell you instead?

Top comments (0)