Most weld rejections on large diameter stainless pipe are not discovered at the mill. They are discovered at the pre-shipment meeting, when someone asks for the radiography report and it turns out the acceptance level was read differently on both sides.
Three decisions fix that before the first plate is rolled.
1. How many welds are in the barrel
A single longitudinal seam (JCOE or LSAW, one seam) and a double-seam barrel are different inspection loads. So is a section closed with a circumferential girth weld. Every seam is a line of weld that has to be examined, and every examination carries a rejection rate. When a mill quotes a 5000 mm outside diameter barrel built from 3000 mm sections joined by girth welds, the quotation should already name the weld count, because that number drives both price and schedule.
2. Which standard, and which class inside it
ASTM A358 is the usual specification above 16 inch, and it does not have one acceptance level. Class 1, 3 and 5 differ in heat treatment and in which testing is mandatory. A purchase order that says "A358" and stops there leaves the mill free to choose. Write the class, and write whether radiography covers the longitudinal seam only or the girth welds as well.
3. What the weld is accepted against
The acceptance criteria is not the standard's table alone. It is the combination of a WPS/PQR qualified under ASME IX, the radiographic technique and acceptance level, and the inspection and test plan signed before production. Ask for the WPS number, the essential variables it covers, and the RT coverage percentage. If the answer is "we always do it this way", there is no document to audit.
The paper trail for an export order
The set is short and specific: WPS/PQR, welder qualification records, RT or UT reports, hydrostatic test record, dimensional report, and an EN 10204 3.1 mill test certificate with heat numbers traceable to the delivered sections. The 3.1 certificate is issued by the manufacturer's own inspection department, which is what separates it from a 2.2 test report.
Where to read the longer version
The process, standard and weld acceptance sequence for this size range is laid out in Shiwang Pipe's guide to large diameter stainless steel welded pipe, including the ten-point checklist used at the pre-shipment meeting.
If the open question is which class applies to your order, the guide to the five classes of ASTM A358 sets out the heat treatment and testing differences line by line.
Top comments (0)