Lies of P Riddle Answers: Complete Arlecchino Phone Puzzle Guide
If you're exploring Lies of P and keep hearing mysterious telephones ringing around Krat, you've discovered one of the game's most interesting optional puzzle chains.
The calls come from Arlecchino, the King of Riddles. Answer his questions correctly and you'll progress toward the Trinity Keys, which open hidden Trinity Sanctums containing valuable rewards.
This guide covers every main Lies of P riddle answer, where to find the phones, and what to do when the solution isn't as straightforward as simply selecting an answer.
Quick Answer List
For players who only need the solutions:
Riddle 1: Human
Riddle 2: Candle
Riddle 3: Egg
Riddle 4: Ergo
Riddle 5: Yes
These are the five commonly documented answers for Arlecchino's main phone-riddle sequence.
How the Riddle System Works
While traveling through Krat, you'll occasionally hear a ringing phone.
Interact with it and Arlecchino presents a riddle.
The basic loop is:
Explore Krat
↓
Hear a ringing phone
↓
Answer Arlecchino's riddle
↓
Receive/progress toward a Trinity Key
↓
Find a Trinity Sanctum
↓
Use the key
↓
Collect the reward
The important part is that the phone location and Trinity Sanctum location aren't necessarily the same.
1. Human — First Riddle
The first riddle appears during the early Krat/Workshop Union section.
Location
Look around the Krat City Hall Courtyard / Workshop Union route and investigate the side paths near the factory approach.
Answer
Human
The riddle is based on the classic question about a creature walking on four legs in the morning, two at midday, and three in the evening.
The solution is a human:
- Baby → crawling on four limbs
- Adult → walking on two legs
- Elderly person → walking with a cane
Key Tip
Don't rush past the phone just because it appears off the main route. Listen for the ringing sound while exploring.
2. Candle — Second Riddle
The second phone is found in Malum District.
Answer
Candle
The clue describes something associated with producing light while gradually being consumed.
This answer advances the Trinity Key quest.
3. Egg — Third Riddle
The third riddle is found in the Grand Exhibition Gallery.
Answer
Egg
This is the riddle that can confuse players because the answer isn't the end of the objective.
After answering Egg, you'll need to follow the clue and solve the related environmental puzzle involving statues.
So if you choose Egg and don't immediately receive the expected result, don't assume the answer was wrong.
The Egg solution is correct.
4. Ergo — Fourth Riddle
The fourth phone appears around Krat Central Station Street.
Answer
Ergo
Ergo is deeply connected to the world and lore of Lies of P, making it a fitting solution to Arlecchino's cryptic question.
Once again, the objective is part of the broader Trinity Key/Sanctum sequence.
5. Yes — Fifth Riddle
The fifth phone encounter occurs late in the game.
Answer
Yes
This response leads into the final stage of the riddle chain and the special Chosen One's Trinity Key.
The final key is associated with the Arche Abbey Trinity Sanctum and the late-game Arlecchino encounter.
Trinity Keys vs. Trinity Sanctums
One of the easiest mistakes is assuming that every riddle phone has a Trinity door nearby.
It doesn't.
Think of the system as two separate collectible steps:
Phone → Riddle → Key
and later:
Trinity Door → Key → Hidden Reward
The five keys allow access to hidden areas containing useful equipment, materials, outfits, and other rewards. Completing the full sequence is also connected to the End of Riddles achievement/trophy.
Fast Checklist
Use this when you're playing:
| # | Phone Area | Answer | Special Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Krat City Hall / Workshop route | Human | Classic four/two/three riddle |
| 2 | Malum District | Candle | Direct answer |
| 3 | Grand Exhibition Gallery | Egg | Follow-up environmental puzzle |
| 4 | Krat Central Station Street | Ergo | Late-game progression |
| 5 | Late-game/Relic route | Yes | Chosen One's Trinity Key |
Common Mistakes
Mistake 1: Ignoring the ringing phone
The phone is easy to miss if you're focused on combat.
Mistake 2: Looking for the Trinity door immediately
The key and door can be in different parts of Krat.
Mistake 3: Thinking Egg is incorrect
The third puzzle requires an additional environmental step after the answer.
Mistake 4: Assuming these answers affect the main Lie/Truth system
The riddle quest is a separate optional puzzle sequence rather than a replacement for the game's broader Lie/Truth mechanics.
Final Cheat Sheet
If you only remember one line, remember this:
HUMAN → CANDLE → EGG → ERGO → YES
Those five answers are the key to solving the main Arlecchino riddle sequence in Lies of P.
If you're aiming for hidden loot, Trinity Sanctums, or the End of Riddles achievement/trophy, keep this checklist handy while exploring Krat.
Top comments (0)