A self-employed borrower walks in with tax returns that say one thing and bank statements that say another. Neither number is wrong. They come from two different methods, and knowing the arithmetic behind each one tells you which documentation path to talk to the lender about.
Educational only, not underwriting, legal or tax advice. The lender decides which documentation it takes and what income it uses.
Method 1: tax return income
The conventional path starts from the tax return. Take net profit for each of the last two years, add back the items the lender allows (depreciation is the common one), and average over 24 months:
monthly = (year1 net profit + year1 add-backs + year2 net profit + year2 add-backs) ÷ 24
Example, a Schedule C borrower:
Year 1: net profit $62,000 + depreciation $8,000
Year 2: net profit $70,000 + depreciation $9,000
($62,000 + $8,000 + $70,000 + $9,000) ÷ 24 = $6,208.33 a month
Method 2: bank statement income
A bank statement loan starts from deposits instead. Total the business deposits for 12 or 24 months (after taking out transfers and refunds), apply the borrower's ownership share, take out the lender's expense factor, and divide by the months:
monthly = total deposits × ownership share × (100% − expense factor) ÷ months
Same borrower, 12 months of business statements:
Deposits $264,000 × 100% ownership × (100% − 50%) ÷ 12 = $11,000.00 a month
Why the gap is so big
The tax return is net of every deduction the borrower's preparer could find. The bank statement method replaces the actual expenses with a flat factor that the lender sets. For a borrower who writes off a lot, the deposit method can come out well above the tax return figure, which is the reason bank statement programs exist.
Things that move the gap:
- The expense factor. It comes from the lender, sometimes from a CPA letter or P&L. A 50% factor and a 30% factor give very different answers.
- Ownership. A 50% owner gets half the deposits.
- What counts as a deposit. Transfers between the borrower's own accounts, refunds and loan proceeds come out.
- 12 vs 24 months. A strong recent year looks better on 12 months; an uneven history is smoothed by 24.
Run your own numbers
The free side-by-side calculator does both formulas from the figures you enter and shows the gap: https://statementready.net/tax-return-vs-bank-statement-income-calculator
For the deposit totals, the free converter turns one statement PDF into rows with a credits total, in your browser: https://statementready.net/bank-statement-converter
For more on the two paths: https://statementready.net/guides/fannie-mae-form-1084-vs-bank-statement-worksheet
Round numbers for illustration only. The expense factor and add-backs are inputs, not defaults from any lender. This is arithmetic, not a lending decision.
Top comments (0)