DEV Community

Cover image for Past weekday winners and losers: the fixed portfolio lost 2.21% a year.
Arnold Holm
Arnold Holm

Posted on

Past weekday winners and losers: the fixed portfolio lost 2.21% a year.

Past weekday winners and losers: the fixed portfolio lost 2.21% a year.

My test of past weekday winners and losers lost money. That 2.21% yearly loss would cost you about 2,200 dollars on a 100,000 dollar account, which eats into your loss limit instead of moving you toward the target.

Why this idea pulls you in

Many traders feel that what worked on a given weekday will keep working on that weekday. You check one weekday and you think the strong ones will stay strong. Past weekday returns can rank an index portfolio. That is the question I tested, and you can see where I keep my results (tested).

What I kept fixed

I kept the rules fixed so the result would be clear. A fixed portfolio bought the top two and sold the bottom two of eleven index markets, ranked by the same weekday over the prior twenty weeks. It lost 2.21% a year in the measured sample. The full run covers the combined data through 2023.

What the wins kept

You pay a fee before you know if an idea works, so you want to see what it kept. A gain that melts away in costs helps no challenge account. For each dollar it lost, it made back about 58 cents. That means the wins did not cover the losses in that run. You stayed below your start while you waited for a turn that did not come. If you check an idea, you want to see wins that pay for losses with room left.

How often a month ended well

You also want to know how often a month ends well. A long wait between good months wears you down and tempts you to quit or to force trades. About 18% of months ended with a gain. That leaves most months flat or down in that run. You would have watched many months go by with no lift for your account. Before you pay, you want an idea that shows good months more often than that.

What this means for your challenge

You do not need a complex read to see why this matters for a challenge. You pay to take part and you must stay above your loss limit while you work toward your target. A steady bleed makes both jobs harder at once. It pulls your account down while the clock runs and fees sit sunk. You start to press and your rules start to slip. That is why I check the basic math before I pay for any test of my own.

Why a fixed set tells you more

I trust a fixed set because it leaves no room to hide a weak patch. You see the same markets through good spells and bad spells alike. You do not get to swap a weak name out after it drags you down. You do not get to add a hot name after it runs up. That honesty helps you when you weigh a fee. You learn if the core idea holds or if it only shone for a short spell.

A check you can run fast

You can run a quick check on your own numbers before you pay. It takes about five minutes and it needs no new math. Open your own report and compare one weekday result with the same weekday across the prior months to see if it holds up. If the same weekday jumps up and down with no clear line, you treat that as doubt. If one weekday holds a clear line across months, you still check costs and rules before you trust it. You want proof that lasts, not one good spell that fades.

What I do with a result like this

I keep my own bar simple when a test looks like this. I would not pay a challenge fee for that weekday ranking because my test lost money year after year. I want to see a clear gain after costs before I risk a fee. You may feel drawn to the idea, and you should let the numbers calm you down. A quiet skip of a weak idea saves your fee for a stronger test.

Fixed set of past weekday winners and losers showing a yearly loss

These are historical test results, not a live account.

You can organise your own rules with the free Prop Rule Guard.

Top comments (0)