DEV Community

Discussion on: We're Building AI to Replace Ourselves. What's the Plan?

Collapse
 
sylwia-lask profile image
Sylwia Laskowska •

Wow, 80,000 characters! That's practically a short story already! And yes, I especially agree with what you said about beginners. It also makes me think about education and schools in general. We now have instant access to pretty much any information we want, but the question is how we use it.

You can blindly copy an answer without understanding a single word, or you can ask an LLM to explain something to you, over and over again, in different ways, until you actually understand it. And that's exactly where the problem lies.

Because in the right hands, AI is an incredible accelerator for learning and personal development. Unfortunately, I'm afraid that for many people, it'll become little more than a machine that provides ready-made answers, gradually replacing the need to think for themselves.

And if that happens, critical thinking will suffer even more. People will become even less likely to question what they see on TV... What do you think?

Collapse
 
pengeszikra profile image
Peter Vivo •

I haven’t watched TV in a very long time, and I wouldn’t really recommend it to anyone. Whenever I watch a film, my “what is the author trying to say?” sensor kicks in immediately. Take Odysseus, for example, which got plenty of criticism for being historically inaccurate. Why was Helen of Troy played by a Black actress? Why did his fleet consist of just three ships? Why did the ships look like Viking ships? Why did they sail west at the end, following the sun? Why does the Greek king look like Batman and Darth Vader rolled into one?

The film itself gives us a clue by repeatedly bringing up the Sea Peoples as the threat of the time. But the deeper answer lies in the way our history education has been steered. At least here in Hungary, the Greeks of Homer’s time and the Greeks of Odysseus’s time were neatly blended together, as if there had been a continuous transition. Yet the events of the Trojan War are dated to 1184 BC, and not long afterward, the entire Bronze Age civilization collapsed. The Greeks lost their knowledge of Linear B and couldn’t read or write for centuries. Homer then composed his works around 725–675 BC, when writing had returned and society had reorganized into city-states.

On top of this, there’s the theory that the work isn’t just about the Trojan War as passed down through legends, but also about a Bronze Age voyage during which the early Greeks may have discovered the American continent. In this reading, there were three ships because they symbolize Columbus’s three ships, and they looked like Viking ships because the Vikings were the first to discover America.

Anyway, here’s a video if anyone is interested in the topic… Sorry for wandering so far off track, but I don’t always stay within IT, and I wouldn’t recommend that to anyone either.

Thread Thread
 
sylwia-lask profile image
Sylwia Laskowska •

Hahaha, I actually love that theory about the ancient Greeks discovering America! I think I might have to watch that movie now!

But you're absolutely right about the media. And the worst offenders, in my opinion, are the news programs, especially here in Poland. Depending on which political party is in power, some channels will tell you everything is absolutely wonderful, while others will insist the country is falling apart. XDDDD

That's actually one of the reasons I stopped watching TV altogether. Although I must admit I made an exception for the World Cup! Which was also pretty disappointing, with all those controversies and questionable decisions, but hey, watching the World Cup has been my tradition since early childhood, and some traditions are hard to give up! 😂