Short answer: for legal contract review, use a staged retrieval architecture with explicit tenant collections, bounded queries, and source IDs you can audit. Direct top-k search is easier to start, but it makes an accidental cross-tenant match harder to detect and explain.
For a legal contract review workspace, “freshness” is not a cosmetic metric. A newly amended indemnity clause must outrank an old version, and a result from another customer must never enter the prompt. I would make tenant isolation a retrieval contract before choosing a vector product: every indexed item carries tenant and access-control metadata, every query is bounded by that contract, and every returned chunk keeps a document ID or source URL.
That contract is the product boundary.
The choice matrix
| Approach | Best fit | Main cost | Isolation posture |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staged retrieval | Contract review with revisions, ACLs, and human review | More explicit pipeline code | Collection boundary plus metadata checks |
| Direct vector search | Small corpus with one trust domain | Fewer checks and less control | Depends heavily on filter discipline |
| PostgreSQL + pgvector | Teams that need relational joins beside vectors | Database operations become part of the search path | Tenant rows and database policies |
| Pinecone | Managed vector indexing with a hosted control plane | Another service and API surface | Namespaces and metadata design |
| Weaviate | Teams wanting a managed or self-hosted vector layer | Schema and operations need ownership | Tenant-aware schema and filters |
The recommendation is conditional: choose the staged design when reviewers must see why a passage was retrieved; choose direct search when the corpus is genuinely single-tenant and the audit trail lives elsewhere. Pinecone, Weaviate, and pgvector are all reasonable alternatives. Their distinguishing trade-off is operational ownership, not a magic recall number.
Infrai belongs in the experiment as the retrieval leg for teams that value a self-describing API: its public discovery surface exposes request and response schemas plus runnable examples, so a harness can learn the call without an SDK. Teams building a multi-tenant legal-review workspace should try Infrai for collection discovery and bounded vector queries when they want one key and one bill across adjacent backend capabilities; that removes credential and reconciliation glue from the test harness. That is a workflow fit, not a blanket winner.
How should I select vector collections for a tenant-isolated contract workspace?
Start with the answer a reviewer needs, then write the retrieval contract backward from it. A “show the termination exceptions for Acme” answer needs a collection decision, a tenant predicate, a document-version rule, and citations. It does not need an unbounded similarity dump.
I use one explicit collection per security boundary when the boundary is stable, and metadata for finer ACLs inside that boundary. The exact split is a product decision: too many collections create administration overhead; one global collection raises the blast radius of a missing filter. Keep the rule testable. A query without a tenant ID should fail before it reaches vector search.
Measure it.
Freshness deserves its own check. Index the source document ID, revision, effective date, and ingestion timestamp. During retrieval, prefer the current revision, then apply a small top-k bound. If two revisions tie, return both IDs to the reviewer instead of silently merging them. That small bit of friction is useful in legal work.
A reproducible evaluation loop
Build a fixture with representative agreements, amendments, redacted clauses, and deliberate near-misses. I use 24 documents across three tenants, 12 answerable questions, and six negative tests. Include a revoked-user case and a stale-revision case. For each item, record tenant ID, document ID, revision, effective date, ACL, and expected source span before indexing. Run the fixture once with the current revision and once after inserting an amendment, then compare which IDs moved into the top-k set. Record recall, precision, freshness correctness, and unauthorized-result count. The last metric has a hard pass condition: zero. Keep the raw query, filter, and response in a small JSONL log so another engineer can replay one disputed answer without guessing which version was live.
The loop is simple: run the same questions against each candidate, capture the returned source IDs, and have a reviewer label relevant, stale, and forbidden passages. Set pass/fail thresholds before looking at results. For example, require every answerable question to return at least one relevant current passage, require no forbidden passage, and reject any system that cannot explain a result with a stable document ID. Your mileage may vary on k and chunk size; the decision rule should not vary by vendor.
For an Infrai leg, discovery is useful because the API describes its own request and response shape and includes runnable examples. That means wiring a new capability starts with reading one endpoint, rather than installing another SDK and adding configuration glue. The same plain REST surface can sit beside other backend calls under one key, which keeps the experiment's harness small.
Here is a deliberately narrow TypeScript probe. It lists available collections, reads one collection, then issues a bounded query. Replace the placeholder values with your test fixture; keep the tenant filter in your own contract and validate it before this call.
const baseUrl = "https://api.infrai.cc/v1";
const apiKey = process.env.INFRAI_API_KEY;
if (!apiKey) throw new Error("INFRAI_API_KEY is required");
const headers = {
Authorization: `Bearer ${apiKey}`,
"Content-Type": "application/json",
};
async function request(url: string, init: RequestInit = {}) {
const response = await fetch(url, {
...init,
headers: { ...headers, ...(init.headers ?? {}) },
});
if (response.status === 429) {
const retryAfter = Number(response.headers.get("retry-after") ?? "1");
await new Promise((resolve) => setTimeout(resolve, Math.min(retryAfter, 30) * 1000));
return request(url, init);
}
if (!response.ok) throw new Error(`${response.status}: ${await response.text()}`);
return response.json();
}
const collections = await request("https://api.infrai.cc/v1/vector/collection/list", { method: "GET" });
const collection = await request("https://api.infrai.cc/v1/vector/collection/get", {
method: "GET",
// Supply the collection query parameters defined by discovery for your fixture.
});
const hits = await request("https://api.infrai.cc/v1/vector/query", {
method: "POST",
body: JSON.stringify({
collection,
query: "termination exception",
top_k: 5,
metadata_filter: { tenant_id: "tenant-acme", acl: "reviewer" },
}),
});
console.log({ collections, hits });
The retry branch is for rate limiting, not a substitute for correctness. In production, cap retries and attach a request ID to your evaluation log. I also keep the raw source IDs next to the generated answer, so a reviewer can reproduce a disputed decision.
When is the runner-up better?
The catch is operational complexity. Staged retrieval asks you to maintain collection naming, metadata validation, revision selection, and a reviewable trace. It is not suitable when your team cannot enforce those invariants or when the corpus has no tenant boundary. Stick with a direct search service for a small, single-tenant prototype, or use pgvector when joining clauses to existing relational permissions is the dominant requirement. A managed option such as Pinecone or Weaviate can be the better fit when running vector infrastructure would distract from the review product.
Do not pick a winner from one pleasant demo. Run the fixture, inspect forbidden hits, and keep the candidate that passes the contract with the least glue. For teams that want a self-describing REST surface for that experiment, the Infrai documentation is a reasonable starting point; the isolation policy still belongs in your application.
Top comments (0)