DEV Community

Cover image for The Arrogance of Having Outgrown Arrogance
Adam - The Developer ✨
Adam - The Developer ✨

Posted on Originally published at a-thedeveloper.vercel.app

The Arrogance of Having Outgrown Arrogance

A few days ago, I met up with a happily retired principal engineer for a chat. He wasn't a complete stranger I'd randomly approached—though I do that sometimes. We'd met at an event a while back but hadn't had much chance to talk.

I asked him all kinds of questions: how he made decisions, how he handled pressure, and what lessons I might learn from his experience. He shared valuable advice, including mistakes he'd made and things he wished he could go back and do differently.

But one thing bothered me a little. Nearly every lesson came with the implication that I was bound to make the same mistake he had, as if he knew I was already walking the same path. He seemed to miss that asking for his wisdom was precisely my attempt to learn from his experience and avoid those mistakes.

The Paradox of Growth

I'd been thinking about this long before that conversation: I don't think we can ever completely escape arrogance. It lives in all of us, and a little arrogance isn't necessarily a bad thing.

We all look back at our younger selves and cringe at our mistakes, poor judgment, and misplaced confidence. But there's something convenient about criticizing who we used to be: our past selves are easy targets because we no longer fully identify with them.

Admitting our past arrogance can reinforce our present identity as someone wiser, someone who knows better. And from where we stand today, it costs very little to judge the person we once were.

But let me ask you—and myself—an uncomfortable question: How do you know you aren't making the very same mistakes your younger self made, just in ways you haven't recognized yet?

What if recognizing our past arrogance is just another form of arrogance?

And if I call the principal engineer arrogant for assuming I'll repeat his mistakes, am I not doing something similar by assuming I understand his thinking? Perhaps there's arrogance in my judgment, too.

That's the contradiction I find so interesting. We can recognize arrogance in others, and even in our past selves, while remaining blind to it in the person we are today.

When Our Virtues Become Another Form of Arrogance

Arrogance doesn't always come from believing we're better than everyone else. Sometimes, it comes from the very qualities we've spent years developing.

  • Take experience, for example. Someone who has spent decades learning from mistakes may genuinely want to spare younger people the same trouble. But they might begin assuming everyone younger must share the ignorance they once had. What took them twenty years to understand might have taken someone else five, or perhaps someone learned the lesson without making the mistake at all.
  • Or consider intelligence. The better we become at reasoning through complex problems, the easier it can be to trust our conclusions. We might carefully examine an argument and still overlook something important. Yet because we've thought so deeply about it, we begin treating the depth of our reasoning as proof of its correctness.
  • Even kindness isn't immune. Someone might offer advice with genuinely good intentions, but in doing so, assume they know what another person needs without ever asking. Their kindness is real, but so is their assumption.

And perhaps most ironically, there's self-awareness.

We might take pride in recognizing our own shortcomings. But what happens when identifying a handful of our flaws convinces us that we understand ourselves completely?

The ability to recognize our own arrogance can itself become a source of arrogance.

None of this makes experience, intelligence, kindness, or self-awareness bad qualities. They're virtues worth developing. But perhaps every virtue carries a temptation: to believe that because we've developed something good within ourselves, we can no longer misuse it.

And that's how arrogance can quietly find its way back in, not by replacing our virtues, but by hiding behind our confidence in them.

Where Confidence Ends and Arrogance Begins

There's an obvious objection to everything above: if recognizing arrogance can be arrogant, and recognizing that can be arrogant too, the argument never ends. Worse, the word stops meaning anything. If every stance counts, including the stance of doubting yourself, then nothing is being said.

So it's worth drawing some lines.

  • Being wrong is a mismatch between a belief and reality. Everyone is wrong constantly, and it says nothing about character.
  • Being confident is holding a belief firmly. Often that's earned. A surgeon who is sure about a procedure she has performed a thousand times isn't arrogant. She's competent. You think I'd want a surgeon who's gonna perform on me telling me: “I’ll try my best”? Fuck no. I want the surgeon who says “relax, I’ve done this a thousand times,” hums while she works, and holds my spleen like it owes her money.

Arrogance is something narrower: confidence that has stopped answering to anything. The arrogant person isn't defined by how sure they are, or by whether they're right, but by whether anything could still change their mind, and whether they've let anyone check.

By that definition, the principal engineer could have been right about every mistake he described and still been arrogant in the way he applied them to me. The content of his advice wasn't the problem. The problem was that he treated his prediction about me as settled without asking whether it fit. The same lessons, offered as "here's what happened to me, does any of this match where you are?", would have been identical in substance and entirely different in spirit.

This also breaks the regress. Ask this instead: what would it take to change my mind, and have I actually given anyone the chance to try? That question has an answer you can check.

What to Do Instead

If arrogance is confidence that no longer answers to anything, then the remedy isn't doubting everything. It's keeping your confidence answerable.

That doesn’t require you to feel humble, which is lucky, because that feeling is exactly the one we're worst at judging in ourselves. It only requires you to leave a door open where someone else can walk in and tell you you're wrong.

Humility Is Never Finished

I don't think recognizing arrogance means we've finally overcome it. We grow older, gain experience, change our opinions, and learn from mistakes that once seemed perfectly reasonable. But becoming wiser than our younger selves doesn't mean we've become immune to the flaws we once possessed.

Humility, to me, isn't about constantly doubting ourselves or refusing to hold strong opinions. We can be confident in what we know while acknowledging that there are things we don't know, including things about ourselves.

And perhaps the most uncomfortable question is this:

  • If your future self were to accuse you of the very arrogance you now recognize in your past, what would you say in your defense?
  • Would you recognize the mistake? Or would you defend yourself with the same confidence your younger self once had?

I certainly don't know all the flaws I possess today. Even the ones I think I understand might only be half the story. And if someone claims to know every flaw they have, perhaps that claim reveals another one.

Ten years from now, I might look back at this very article and cringe at how confidently I wrote about arrogance and humility. If I've kept the door open, someone will have told me so sooner.

And if that happens, I hope I'll have learned something worth cringing about.

Perhaps humility isn't something we finally achieve. Perhaps it's the willingness to accept that we haven't finished learning how to be humble.

Top comments (0)