Backlink reporting has an honesty problem. It is very easy to produce a number that looks like success and means nothing.
After running a multi-site campaign, here is the measurement discipline that actually held up.
The one rule that matters
An asset counts only if you have seen a live page containing a real anchor element pointing at your exact host, and you have read its rel attribute.
Everything else is a candidate. "Submitted", "accepted", "should be live" — these are states, not links. The gap between submitted and live is large enough that conflating them produces reports that are off by an order of magnitude.
The states worth tracking
Instead of a boolean, track a small state machine:
- Discovered — the site exists and accepts submissions
- Submitted — the form was successfully completed
- Live — a page exists that links to us
- Verified — the live page's anchor element was fetched and its rel read
Only Verified contributes to the number. The earlier states are useful for scheduling re-checks, not for reporting.
The rel attribute is the whole game
A dofollow link and a nofollow link are different products. Most directory and comment channels produce nofollow by default. If you do not read the rel, you will happily report hundreds of links that do nothing.
The check is mechanical: fetch the page, find the anchor, parse rel. Do it rather than trusting the platform's marketing.
Re-check on a schedule
Links die quietly. Pages get deleted, sites redesign, directories prune stale listings. A campaign that was successful in month one can be substantially eroded by month three, and you will not see it unless you re-check.
Set a re-check schedule at submission time: three days, then two weeks, then monthly. The re-check is where the real number lives.
What this looks like in practice
https://airapvideo.one/ is the site the campaign was built around, and the honest count after the first weeks was a handful of verified dofollow links — not the hundreds of submissions. That gap is the report.
If your backlink report has more submissions than verified links and you are not explaining the difference, the report is not measuring anything.
Top comments (0)