Why Did Clarence Thomas Warn About the First Amendment? Supreme Court Rejects California Case
Why did Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas warn about the First Amendment? The question attracted attention after the US Supreme Court declined to hear a legal challenge to California's mandatory implicit-bias training requirement for medical education courses.
On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court rejected a request to review Khatibi v. Yip, a case involving California's requirement that continuing medical education courses address implicit bias.
Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the decision, arguing that the lower court's reasoning could allow governments to avoid constitutional free-speech protections simply by regulating private speech.
Justice Neil Gorsuch also indicated that he would have heard the case.
The dispute has raised questions about whether governments can require private instructors to include particular viewpoints in professional training and whether such requirements violate the First Amendment.
But what exactly did Clarence Thomas say, who challenged California's requirement, and did the Supreme Court overturn the state's training rule?
Here is what happened.
Why Did Clarence Thomas Warn About the First Amendment?
Clarence Thomas warned that governments should not be able to escape First Amendment scrutiny by describing privately delivered speech as government speech simply because the activity is regulated.
His warning followed the Supreme Court's refusal to review California's implicit-bias training requirement for continuing medical education courses.
Thomas argued that the Ninth Circuit's reasoning could allow a state to classify privately delivered instruction as government speech whenever it exercises extensive regulatory control over a profession.
In his written dissent, Thomas stated:
A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny.
His concern was that the government's regulatory authority could be used to require private speakers to communicate particular government-preferred messages without facing the usual constitutional scrutiny.
Thomas argued that courts should examine who is actually speaking rather than automatically treating regulated private instruction as government speech.
He also warned that the reasoning could have consequences beyond medical education, potentially affecting other regulated professions and professional training programmes.
What Did Clarence Thomas Say in His Supreme Court Dissent?
Thomas argued that the lower court misunderstood the distinction between government speech and private speech.
The government is generally allowed to communicate its own messages. However, the First Amendment protects private individuals from government interference with their expression.
Thomas questioned whether California was genuinely speaking through its own government programme or requiring private instructors to communicate a message selected by the state.
He argued that the fact that California regulates medical education does not automatically make everything taught in private medical courses government speech.
Thomas also questioned the Supreme Court's existing approach to identifying government speech, known as the government-speech doctrine.
He referred to the 2022 case Shurtleff v. Boston, arguing that its framework could allow extensive government regulation to be confused with government authorship of private expression.
Thomas suggested that the Supreme Court should reconsider that framework.
His dissent was joined by Justice Samuel Alito.
What Happened in Khatibi v. Yip?
Khatibi v. Yip was a First Amendment case involving California ophthalmologist Dr. Azadeh Khatibi and the medical advocacy organisation Do No Harm.
They challenged California's requirement that continuing medical education courses include instruction addressing implicit bias.
The case reached the Supreme Court after the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the challengers.
The appeals court treated the content of the regulated medical education courses as government speech, meaning the First Amendment challenge could not proceed on the basis argued by the plaintiffs.
Khatibi and Do No Harm asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.
However, on November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeal.
This means the Supreme Court did not issue a new ruling deciding whether California's requirement violates the First Amendment.
The lower court's decision remains in place.
Why Are California Doctors Challenging Implicit Bias Training?
The dispute centres on California's requirement that qualifying continuing medical education courses address implicit bias.
Implicit bias generally refers to unconscious attitudes or assumptions that can influence how people perceive or treat others.
California introduced the requirement through legislation passed in 2019, with the relevant curriculum requirement taking effect in 2022.
Under the law, qualifying courses must include either:
- Examples of how implicit bias may affect physicians' perceptions and treatment decisions, potentially contributing to differences in health outcomes.
- Strategies for addressing how unintended biases in decision-making may contribute to healthcare disparities.
California requires licensed physicians to complete continuing medical education as part of maintaining their professional licences.
Dr. Khatibi challenged the requirement because she argued that the state was compelling private medical instructors to include a particular viewpoint in their courses.
Her challenge was not simply about whether doctors should learn about bias. It concerned whether the government could require private instructors to deliver specified content under a state licensing and education framework.
California defended the requirement, arguing that it was part of its authority to regulate medical education and protect patients.
The state also argued that instructors were not required to personally endorse the concept of implicit bias and could explain their disagreement with it.
Which Supreme Court Justices Disagreed With the Decision?
Three Supreme Court justices indicated that they would have heard the challenge.
They were:
| Justice | Position |
|---|---|
| Clarence Thomas | Would have heard the case and wrote a dissent |
| Samuel Alito | Joined Thomas's written dissent |
| Neil Gorsuch | Separately indicated that he would have heard the case |
Four votes are required for the Supreme Court to agree to hear a case.
The three justices who supported reviewing the challenge were therefore one vote short.
An important distinction is that Gorsuch did not join Thomas and Alito's written dissent. He separately indicated that he would have granted the petition.
The Court's refusal to hear the case does not mean all the justices agreed with the lower court's reasoning.
Did the Supreme Court Overturn California's Implicit Bias Training Requirement?
No. The Supreme Court did not overturn California's implicit-bias training requirement.
It declined to review the case, leaving the Ninth Circuit's decision in place.
This distinction is important because refusing to hear an appeal is not the same as issuing a ruling on the underlying constitutional question.
The Supreme Court did not decide that California's requirement is constitutional, nor did it strike it down.
For now, the requirement remains in effect under the existing legal position.
What Is Government-Compelled Speech?
Government-compelled speech refers to situations in which the government requires individuals or organisations to communicate a particular message.
The First Amendment generally protects people from being forced by the government to express messages they do not wish to communicate.
However, the legal analysis can become complicated when the government regulates professional education, licensing, accreditation or other activities involving private organisations.
In Khatibi v. Yip, the central question was whether California's requirement regulated private instructors' speech or whether the instruction should be treated as government speech.
Thomas argued that the government should not be able to avoid constitutional scrutiny simply by regulating the environment in which private speech takes place.
The Supreme Court did not resolve that question when it declined to hear the appeal.
What Happens Next After the Supreme Court Rejected the Case?
Because the Supreme Court declined to review the case, the Ninth Circuit's ruling remains in place.
This means California's implicit-bias training requirement continues to operate under the existing legal framework.
The decision does not establish a new nationwide Supreme Court rule declaring that all government-mandated professional training is constitutional.
It also does not mean that every future challenge to compulsory professional education will have the same outcome.
The constitutional debate over government speech and compelled speech remains relevant to other cases involving professional regulation and private expression.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Clarence Thomas warn about the First Amendment?
Thomas warned that governments could use extensive regulation to classify private speech as government speech, potentially avoiding First Amendment scrutiny of compulsory messages.
What did Clarence Thomas say about free speech?
He argued that First Amendment protections do not disappear simply because a state heavily regulates speech. He also stated that a state cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny.
What happened in Khatibi v. Yip?
The Supreme Court declined to review a challenge to California's requirement that qualifying continuing medical education courses address implicit bias. Thomas and Alito dissented from the refusal to hear the case.
Who challenged California's implicit bias training requirement?
California ophthalmologist Dr. Azadeh Khatibi and the medical advocacy organisation Do No Harm challenged the requirement.
Why did the Supreme Court reject the California doctor training case?
The Supreme Court denied the petition for review. It did not issue a detailed majority explanation deciding the underlying First Amendment dispute.
Did Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito agree?
Yes. Samuel Alito joined Thomas's written dissent arguing that the Court should have reviewed the case.
Did Neil Gorsuch join Clarence Thomas's dissent?
No. Gorsuch separately indicated that he would have granted the petition to hear the case, but he did not join Thomas and Alito's written dissent.
Is California's implicit bias training requirement still in effect?
Yes. The Supreme Court's refusal to hear the case left the Ninth Circuit's ruling in place, so the requirement remains in effect.
Does the Supreme Court decision mean California's law is constitutional?
No. The Court declined to review the challenge. It did not issue a ruling deciding whether the requirement violates the First Amendment.
What is compelled speech under the First Amendment?
Compelled speech involves government action requiring individuals or organisations to communicate a particular message. Whether a specific requirement violates the First Amendment depends on the legal circumstances.
Final Takeaway
Clarence Thomas's First Amendment warning followed the Supreme Court's decision not to review California's mandatory implicit-bias training requirement for medical education courses.
Thomas, joined by Samuel Alito, argued that governments should not be able to turn private speech into government speech simply by regulating the profession in which that speech occurs.
Neil Gorsuch also supported hearing the case, but did not join the written dissent.
The Supreme Court's decision did not overturn California's requirement or settle whether it violates the First Amendment. The Ninth Circuit's ruling remains in place.
The wider question raised by the case is how far government regulation can go before it interferes with the constitutional protections afforded to private speakers.
Sources and Further Reading
- US Supreme Court – Khatibi v. Yip, No. 25-1240 (November 16, 2026)
- Cornell Legal Information Institute – Khatibi v. Yip
- The Hill – Supreme Court won't review implicit bias mandate for California medical courses
- Pacific Legal Foundation – Justice Thomas dissents as Supreme Court declines doctors' challenge
Related Articles
- Where did the warship wreck happen, how was it found, and which Royal Navy warship was it?
- What Happened in the Shamell Naquan Joyner Case, What Evidence Was Presented, and Latest Updates: Shamell Naquan Joyner Jury Evidence
- Pandemic and Climate Change: Why the Next Global Health Crisis Could Come From the Weather
- Why Did Christa Pike's Execution Fail? What Her Lawyers Say
Originally published at Flames Nova
Top comments (0)