DEV Community

Asael Shinder
Asael Shinder

Posted on

Someone Who Joined After You Got the Promotion You Wanted

The announcement arrives in the team channel on a Tuesday morning. Your colleague has been promoted to senior engineer. They joined eighteen months after you, you helped them with their first deployment, and you had been told, more or less, that you were in line for exactly this. Everyone is posting congratulations. You are staring at the screen.

It is fine to feel hurt, or angry, or embarrassed. Do not act on any of it today. Do not reply in the channel with something clipped, and do not book a meeting with your manager while your voice is still unsteady. Give it a day.

Then do the hard part first. Congratulate your colleague, briefly and sincerely, in a direct message. They did not take anything from you. Promotions are rarely a contest between two named people, and the relationship you keep with them will matter for years.

Next, ask your manager for a conversation, and go in curious rather than wounded. Your questions are simple. What did the panel see in their case that it did not see in mine? Was I considered at all this round? What would need to be true for me to be promoted next cycle, and what evidence would show it? Write the answers down and send them back afterwards, so you both have the same version.

Listen for the kind of answer you get. Sometimes it is specific and fair. You have not led anything that crosses team boundaries, or your work has been strong but invisible to anyone outside the team. That is useful, and you can act on it. Sometimes it is about timing or budget, which is frustrating but honest. And sometimes it is vague, the same vague words you heard last year. That is worth noticing too.

Length of service is not usually what promotion panels look for. They look for evidence that you are already working at the next level. If you have been waiting your turn, this is the moment to stop waiting and start collecting that evidence on purpose.

Give it one more cycle with a clear, written target. If the target keeps moving after that, you have learned something about the company, and it may be time to see how the market values you.

– Asael Shinder

Top comments (0)