Your manager shares the slides for tomorrow's meeting with the leadership team, asking if anyone has comments. You look at the chart on page four. It says the new checkout reduced failed payments by forty per cent. You helped produce that number, and you know it compares one month before the change with one month after, and the month after included a public holiday with half the usual traffic. The real improvement is much smaller.
Your first thought is that you must be wrong, or that it is not your place. Your second is that it is late, and nobody likes changes the night before. Both thoughts are understandable. Neither is a good reason to stay quiet.
Think about what happens if you say nothing. Leadership makes decisions based on a number you know is wrong. Somebody may notice later, and your manager will be the person who presented it. Telling them now is not criticism. It is protecting them.
So check first, quickly. Look at the data again, and make sure you can explain the problem in two sentences. If you can produce a better figure, do it, even roughly.
Then tell your manager privately, today, and not as a comment on the shared document where others will see it. Keep it short and practical. I think the forty per cent on page four overstates it. The comparison month had a bank holiday. Comparing the same weekdays gives about twelve per cent. Here is the working. Offer a fix, not just a problem. One corrected line on the slide, or a note saying the figure is provisional.
Expect a moment of frustration. That is normal the night before a presentation, and it is usually directed at the situation, not at you. Most managers will be grateful by the morning.
If your manager decides to keep the figure, you have done your part. Make sure your concern is in writing, kindly, and let it go unless the mistake could cause real harm.
Confidence at work is often this quiet. Not speaking up in the big meeting, but sending an uncomfortable message the evening before, so the big meeting goes well.
– Asael Shinder
Top comments (0)