DEV Community

Cover image for Why OKRs Fail on a Project Model (and How Funding Fixes It)
Ayush Bisht
Ayush Bisht

Posted on Edited on

Why OKRs Fail on a Project Model (and How Funding Fixes It)

You rolled out OKRs. A few quarters later, the objectives sit on slides, the key results read like a delivery plan, and your team still gets a prioritized list from above. Sound familiar? You are not alone, and the fix is not a better template.

The root cause

Marty Cagan at SVPG calls this the most common problem when companies try to focus on outcomes: they assume they can move to outcomes without moving to the product model. OKRs grew out of that model and assume its conditions: empowered teams, discovery, a product strategy and instrumented products. Drop OKRs onto an output-based roadmap process and nothing about how decisions get made changes.

Five failure patterns

  1. Deliverable key results. "Ship v2 dashboard" is a task, not a result.
  2. Stakeholder-chosen initiatives. Leaders attach initiatives to each objective and hand them down.
  3. No discovery before commitment. Solutions are locked in at planning time.
  4. No link to funding or capacity. Budgets stay annual and project-based regardless of OKR progress.
  5. Uninfluenceable outcomes. A team owns a company-level revenue number it cannot move directly.

That last one is nasty. Hand a team a result it has no lever for and accountability turns into blame, which pushes people back to counting outputs.

Rewrite your key results

Instead of: Launch one-click checkout by Q3
Try: Reduce checkout abandonment from [baseline] to [target] by [date]

Instead of: Ship the new onboarding tour
Try: Increase the share of new users completing setup in week one

Instead of: Release 12 integrations
Try: Raise the share of accounts using at least one integration

The outcome version is harder because you need a baseline and a way to measure. If your product cannot show whether the number moved, instrumentation comes before the OKR.

Connect the money

This is the part most teams skip. Think of funding as the money rule, OKRs as the goal-statement technique and the roadmap as a view of outcomes over time. If any one is output-based, the others follow it. So move to:

  • Allocation by outcome goal: plan capacity per goal and compare with actual.
  • Staged funding: release the next tranche when evidence shows progress.

A healthier quarter

  1. Leaders set a few company objectives and the problems most worth solving.
  2. Teams propose outcome-style key results they can influence.
  3. Teams run discovery and bring evidence, not feature lists.
  4. Mid-quarter reviews look at outcome movement, not delivery status.
  5. At quarter end, leaders reallocate capacity and funding on evidence.

Quick sanity check

Ask yourself six questions. Are key results outcomes? Do teams choose initiatives? Does discovery happen before commitment? Is progress reviewed on evidence? Can objectives change when evidence changes? Does funding respond to progress? Score 0 to 3 and you have a relabelled roadmap. Score 6 and OKRs are probably working.

Should you drop OKRs? Not necessarily. Diagnose first. If teams have no say in solutions and no discovery, fix those, then use OKRs to state outcomes clearly.

Full guide with templates (outcome brief, funding release memo, quarterly review agenda): https://productleadersdayindia.org/blogs/ai-driven-product-operating-model/outcome-based-funding-and-allocation.html

How does your team handle this? Tell me in the comments.


DEV settings to fill in separately:
Tags: productmanagement, agile, career, leadership
Canonical URL: https://productleadersdayindia.org/blogs/ai-driven-product-operating-model/outcome-based-funding-and-allocation.html

Top comments (0)