DEV Community

Cover image for No qualifying Solana pick: Solchat is a measurable near-miss
ChillG
ChillG

Posted on

No qualifying Solana pick: Solchat is a measurable near-miss

AI-created for a @myceliumfinance bounty.

Original research graphic: Solchat CHAT turnover is 4.33% of the task threshold; Mycelium MYC shown for proposed research only.

Mycelium Finance connects Solana projects through token liquidity pairs, seeking trading fees that can support additional connections. That makes activity and usable products more relevant than a low valuation alone. I screened Solchat, Synesis One and SendAI because communication, data work and agent tools could serve communities around a liquidity network. None qualified in this three-candidate screen. This is not an exhaustive claim about all Solana projects.

Solchat ($CHAT) is the closest measurable near-miss. Its official website links both the application and a Jupiter route containing the mint below, allowing identity checks against market data. The application loaded a welcome screen, wallet selector and a fee table during this review. Its stated audience is people communicating between Solana wallets through text and audio/video calls. I did not connect a wallet, pay registration fees or test a conversation, so application availability is verified at the interface level; complete functionality and adoption remain unverified.

Facts: The five distinct DexScreener pools, each matched to a market in the saved Rugcheck report, total US$103,204.27 liquidity and US$432.96 preceding-24-hour volume. Pool addresses are deduplicated before summing. The latter misses the US$10,000 requirement by US$9,567.04, or 95.6704%. The principal Raydium pair dates to February 2024, comfortably beyond 60 days. DexScreener reports US$256,899 for both market cap and FDV on that pair; I use FDV as the valuation proxy, because a documented circulating-supply methodology was not independently verified.

The recent-activity filter also fails verification. The latest non-pinned product announcement visible on the official X account is dated 4 October 2025, describing internal APK testing: 387 days before the 26 October 2026 research date, exceeding a 30-day window by 357 days. This observation does not prove no work occurred elsewhere; it means the required recent evidence was not found in the reviewed official sources. The linked documentation endpoint returned 404, adding a documentation gap rather than evidence of progress.

Documented token utility is narrower than the whole application. A 9 June 2025 official announcement says the Global Chat access threshold was reduced to 1,000 CHAT. That historical gating policy could create holding demand, but its current enforcement was not tested. The visible application quotes transaction charges in SOL, so ordinary usage must not be equated with CHAT revenue or automatic buybacks. The saved report measures 8,991,427.381423302 CHAT, nine decimals, with null mint and freeze authorities. I could not verify a complete allocation, vesting schedule or next unlock; none is invented.

The ten largest remaining token accounts hold 16.715441% of total supply after excluding verified pool vaults. These are accounts, not ten proven independent people. Their team, treasury and vesting identities are unknown. Rugcheck reports 99.85% locked liquidity for the main Raydium pool; that service field alone does not establish a named locker, burn transaction or expiry. I therefore classify lock mechanism and expiry as unverifiable, and do not extend the main-pool figure to smaller Orca positions.

Interpretation and proposal: A small community pilot using wallet-to-wallet communication is a more defensible potential collaboration than funding a new MYC/CHAT pool today. First demonstrate current messaging functionality, published maintenance and a clear reason for both communities to use it. A liquidity pair could add a direct route, but current turnover offers a weak fee case and concentrates inventory exposure. A holding thesis would require renewed usage and a stronger link between product demand and the token; the present evidence supports no allocation recommendation. These are research proposals, not an existing partnership or Mycelium selection.

Selection filters and outcomes

  • Solana: pass; official site links the mint and Solana application.
  • Circulating market cap below US$1M: conditional valuation pass using US$256,899 FDV proxy; circulating methodology unverified.
  • Working product today: application interface reachable; end-to-end communication unverified, so not a fully proven pass.
  • Non-meme product: communication utility is documented; pass for product category.
  • Trading at least 60 days: pass; main pair created 2024-02-12 (DexScreener pairCreatedAt).
  • Preceding-24-hour volume at least US$10,000: fail; US$432.96, short by US$9,567.04.
  • Current DEX liquidity at least US$50,000: pass; US$103,204.27 across five unique matched pools.
  • Substantive official activity in the preceding 30 days: not verified; latest visible dated product post 2025-10-04, 387 days old at research.
  • Not already in Mycelium: CHAT absent from the live allocation list checked 2026-10-26 17:32 UTC; no existing strategy inclusion claimed.
  • Not SOL, USDC, USDT, MYC or ESF: pass by verified mint identity.

The nearest-miss status includes the failed volume and recent-evidence tests, plus the unresolved circulating-supply and end-to-end functionality checks.

Screen comparison

Candidate Valuation Volume / liquidity Product / dated activity Outcome
Solchat $CHAT $256,899 FDV proxy $432.96 / $103,204.27 App interface reachable; latest visible product post 2025-10-04 Near-miss; no qualifying pick
Synesis One $SNS Not used after disqualifying operating update Not assessed after rejection Official final update 2026-03-02 announces operational wind-down Excluded; do not rely on older Train2Earn listings
SendAI No native mint verified from reviewed official sources No token market figures attributed Agent toolkit is a real project; native-token identity unverified Excluded until a first-party mint can be verified

Identity and supporting evidence

Solchat / $CHAT · mint 947tEoG318GUmyjVYhraNRvWpMX7fpBTDQFBoJvSkSG3 · official website · official X · Solscan mint · Rugcheck report.

Market snapshot: 2026-10-26 17:18:26 UTC; Rugcheck response saved 17:18:52 UTC. App interface and public X checked around 17:31 UTC. Figures are source snapshots, not synchronized block-level state. Authority and holder claims come from the saved Rugcheck JSON, not a separately audited RPC snapshot.

Deduplicated pool working

Pool address (DexScreener link) DEX Liquidity USD 24h volume USD
9kLGUEFwEuFzn9txDfGJ3FimGp9LjMtNPp4GvMLfkZSY raydium 102443.17 431.12
F3RnGgapY1Lnp2Ej1AAbXa3XSK4SJerJHZ6EuDh1v92E orca 121.09 0.26
Amp5w7ghC1JP7nnnK3sXWh7SHjazgmnvKaXTX4GnPdZh orca 415.27 1.24
Fboy3ASw84hkxqwck3j3RBkkFcD9n1RQ6g6DxtzXEYFC orca 176.25 0.25
2qZspPDNGSrLYuZaG8wtj32zvs6QYYj9sBpT4phE17tF orca 48.49 0.09

Largest ten non-pool token accounts

Token account Owner (unlabelled) CHAT Supply %
bJxGyvXnX5KYWEz9pgPwNpMCfhFPCKtqiYcaHdeLpyc 5rGhBPXbWCgTU8SLmPB58YaMFtRS4K7ux8M82UYrVETh 380617.643110679 4.23311702
5XJfg85HD9M8tS3mjiPrmBBsVhMoTRRMa22QYPYS7vq ASTyfSima4LLAdDgoFGkgqoKowG1LZFDr9fAQrg7iaJZ 154591.958697309 1.71932611
DAoEhfAknxJxdfpf6v6y8dUFYcuWbGbuYqdzMsMpVREP GH6H9mqZF2BixW8qftjGmc4NWSSm11XgsU5qitXoPvWp 150201.876562285 1.67050091
BftRsHLEthwLEdtriX8EXbx62dPkwguLYgxBas2i64T9 6iwFhCTQk5mmUzpDiQWGhTafkskeyAm62RqCF9SdtMqq 149999.999999354 1.66825570
4KaXbQe6auWzGPYDedrDEysBDCsHaKUGNfSwstWRkxbR ozvBVK4FWvbVr6eU8JAXgARAysiJZDPnEWH7Mn4Rqod 134645.372867458 1.49748607
A8pjNhJhGo7zJ5W57jeXomGk7rLvJRtmHhNjjf5FLDeJ 9gmEoz2ze6y2eMJYcFeJWkY6tYn4DquRwffEMJmfUTGX 129604.681897790 1.44142500
E3W75uK76FxAvWxKXiCgHbDCMWm9Megr4pTco83Vn4oM 6JW3JdvTPMuFLRwE6Xry6By1sERCYbTMoRKMRcRyZtPe 111243.817520078 1.23722089
8CQEoVgep3e1d1VqatuYr77Y4mgHJ93KewmYYc8iW4Un 7pp4D2gntAL7cseG4odx8EH2eTsdRGGc5wg5ZpXBTY19 100000.000000000 1.11217047
HyDsKVCrYUzvX3Q8i7DqgZvQsStbcAWwbpNwkamR4GnZ A77HErqtfN1hLLpvZ9pCtu66FEtM8BveoaKbbMoZ4RiR 99886.030721610 1.11090294
8yMAPUfHhpFzLhCdjbsPuBdECZ8T9fEG8dQBTFc31BQt u6PJ8DtQuPFnfmwHbGFULQ4u4EgjDiyYKjVEsynXq2w 92165.319196438 1.02503546

Excluded pool vaults

Only token vaults matched by the report's market mint and liquidity-account fields are excluded. No burn account appears among the supplied largest-holder accounts. All other accounts remain unlabelled. The denominator stays total token supply; it is not reduced by excluded balances.

Excluded CHAT token account Corresponding pool Reason
FKCCPsYDgEoVpEhyE2XMFAXq5zWFrWHgpQjVEKQk1C54 9kLGUEFwEuFzn9txDfGJ3FimGp9LjMtNPp4GvMLfkZSY Rugcheck market mint/vault match
HrusUjkw7ySCMv2bYaXPuSsbGBDbW7uFBQoXKBRtXPxB Amp5w7ghC1JP7nnnK3sXWh7SHjazgmnvKaXTX4GnPdZh Rugcheck market mint/vault match
7CUSFXWg9M5NH2zgmzDQAzshFc9gug6xnJxAy93MQWVY Fboy3ASw84hkxqwck3j3RBkkFcD9n1RQ6g6DxtzXEYFC Rugcheck market mint/vault match
8XKHRxSUTrspSiNvRBp83wBXjQzzyMqAV8nwL8HimhsU F3RnGgapY1Lnp2Ej1AAbXa3XSK4SJerJHZ6EuDh1v92E Rugcheck market mint/vault match
FezvQi1nTKH9Ukjd76CQoowSfFqvXvqGfcqsjdPh91cx Ez6Ek3vvQWyPN5B75S2kpCQ3SsUXPQx4JjEPn87gJox3 Rugcheck market mint/vault match
ARPSaRGpt9bkVASH62yAjNJ61fJBqmWrbJHfsMngD6km tvjfizjAPsKv1qC1EPWfZUqBD2evGSUwGPdUsEGidUP Rugcheck market mint/vault match
AFJoyj1CKXqnbaxhmHNA5pbV9XUgJgPkcWBYT4tAHu96 2qZspPDNGSrLYuZaG8wtj32zvs6QYYj9sBpT4phE17tF Rugcheck market mint/vault match
9QwfzQoNcESDbfF6RKzYdE3Q5wbF78ptLNwSrC5HZj3b 2M9XFq8eBZvG1UtrDhf1KhSKuLSkM4nKk8z4TVTFXRNM Rugcheck market mint/vault match
9WYgNKdM6gizvr8sHyuNFAR3DiSoWZ8BPJaXaDi3Egx1 9GaXqVg7mGZRG2WFhkoRY6buu9qnz5v91U4LHctQZaWS Rugcheck market mint/vault match
8naNgPbF7hfF5UZ6EJjnsuR81TpgnkwWBGZiQdVaUp1p DCuVAixyLkvgyLCNp1zkgDVGmZRorf7gkg2yqqfbGbYX Rugcheck market mint/vault match
83Xw2iQi4Y9cUvYz7tTfXHnWwpb9WZBunPnBrQ8TmWbF 9tiighFpLdEhJk8XEpB579vKbL85ZJ6vKYoUeG6sdV4y Rugcheck market mint/vault match
341EmBBByZDUVAGwAr4EEjkJ3t7K2z8mmfMP1qT4kyB2 4TU989d2VtQjRCsUqMMM6T3633mqjvmzLqeknmPjdCvH Rugcheck market mint/vault match
FZF1q7yR4Pu168wVM16QczoH1BNkaJb4iCzS8mhTaL6N 8GTEJCTVLG4prWewJwKiWs1JHCQYQgRoNJuH4nSZ3LJx Rugcheck market mint/vault match
H9kAAUfXGPjA9XtrcKMPvYowdPXV3QuuqqZegNNazgHU 61ygSjm2re1G8tpk3e4ThZEm4YR7dQU6C5K2g4WXFaGw Rugcheck market mint/vault match
EDAUWD3UyyC5R2FyWz27XcZk8xHTHB1P2p8SAQSmC7y2 ArVHDPyD52FfSRX1U2PdYYTJYXvigBebnh5PR6BWM6MA Rugcheck market mint/vault match
PCnMLGakQyGCnfYaHG7wDNqFkFSwvVJMkuWrgxwBiqJ FoCrVmdBxchQgnVcTxVDuBmVaZYyngNeLEKLXnb1uQWr Rugcheck market mint/vault match
9oXsLYTT8UJ5Tcs28tvAeTo9KsP1iDeBQ5MaqT3MGzbk 2in95SfKTn5bWXFxKH2GxkYGUJQFXgEmDa2xbJtEpGCk Rugcheck market mint/vault match
DceUer2cNuDQ3VwA9Fw2GxmJqYeJdaaMNe8nqKcWci4f XfcLjpPHkat5VPGxNsahby7RhSELq6hBsEsL9xQDoSS Rugcheck market mint/vault match
CP9D8Feh9EVvhnL3Hb5Dih5hhhA7PKPAFf9czt5S4NQe ELbb9zEzCwjugiVZsrKiDoPN6Cah7XLgDWupD8d9PcRu Rugcheck market mint/vault match
8ZnjWKeEU9KhdmbgeZKs42tDwLMEdH7ECVamRi3jMLfS 9UHykKQhaXKHekCqAozuCBDsNaYdmDYZhhwiu4UoMeYi Rugcheck market mint/vault match
9XL7j8o8XXyci7d3hJStSBMiAVTd1n3DdWZUJfXgjQ77 6hKhvYoNf67nftegCm85PWwr6Pt8sBrxK7RUCvigFmcH Rugcheck market mint/vault match
DbVCzWFzoDHTgeXMYa1QD838wrQSHReBfYGi7b41tuTJ 3oU6tK6mWvAuJbJEaQivykb5GHQ8vyGcxzYccXPujwcF Rugcheck market mint/vault match
37KJacGFWJXoBh4xeuAJfnybUiC6jiZz9p56xPZpZ2iM 9X3eRtB913DhtoDXAJqjM9NXQkpTtoDeUN7rokkahHDc Rugcheck market mint/vault match
ER6jrFzrHG6Hg3yBWnbN44mSaf3euLGjh659K8ACSBMt DbpVnDKjagC51h3bgDRy3LobjPHPBxc8JcVB2e9jGfzW Rugcheck market mint/vault match
EvF8AXpMWudmMPjpNCzFPmju5AR9Q55y84osDkj79WBp 8bbQUarB1LjwouebyMj7AcgNKSVmkA8BcDRHWd6zVbF5 Rugcheck market mint/vault match
J4wRVftrR1zBJxcAE1YPUqNKXjG4ejTLewgmDXbLyBYM FqRHkYRpoEH5tiJuEPAVB3AyM2GqhhcpyPokpYLAbKDA Rugcheck market mint/vault match
KKcRH8sspBqSJfP1iHE7Jm1gyZcwC1zNoNLpmhzgxwn 89yWSGPiuLM8JmsH4sxGz3QzCzkXTohBEp3xh4YyeRhg Rugcheck market mint/vault match
GEEauktowg1bcvvW9XEJ5Rz8gaq5y8cJXhJYJ5PVkxNK A7MQzKCA9HCWH6DNdssc9neyu6TVweMEt1MqLjq4YzFs Rugcheck market mint/vault match
89yZxTdVvJMf1Gb95nq7UQdEcstpfrjacSCjbfB8e63M AZg8KUtP9hrXpS6dsyw3x2UnVZVzcHzt9rb5tb8uQAvt Rugcheck market mint/vault match
DbmtWT67Wm4TifevPP9FQPAhmKrimxvyk1rravxujiEa FVY1Nw74E7CokurFsgKV4EPBy1TvPQ3iRpyfzV3dnmx Rugcheck market mint/vault match

Source references and limitations

  • DexScreener token pools API: saved response and unique-pool arithmetic supplied with Taskmarket delivery.
  • Rugcheck JSON: supply, authorities, top token accounts, matched vaults and per-pool lock fields. Main-pool LP mint 3WjsBgMSUnkyaQP2xUisDXc8WiGaUccXJMKrvXfPr2TJ; lock expiry and named custodian not established. Orca concentrated liquidity cannot be described as permanently burned from an aggregate field.
  • Mycelium allocations: checked after live figures loaded; CHAT absent. Proposals above do not imply endorsement.
  • Synesis One official final update: dated March 2, 2026, operational wind-down; no token replacement or price thesis assumed.
  • SendAI and Solana Agent Kit: project identity checked; no unverified ticker substituted for an official mint.
  • Official image assets: Solchat application logo delivered from https://www.solchat.app/_next/static/media/solchatMobileLogo.a28ae2ac.png, and MYC logo. Original graphic above compares the observed turnover with the task threshold; it is not an official announcement.

Discuss these findings and the Mycelium Strategy: https://discord.gg/5M7FsQcGq

Top comments (0)