This week I submitted my product to five directories. I kept a log, because I wanted to know what "free" actually buys you.
Here it is, unedited:
Directory Cost Wait
Launching Next $0 In queue, "estimated wait: 4 months." $99 for 24 hours.
FutureTools $0 A few days, human review
Insidr AI $0 No timeline, no guarantee of publication
TopAI.tools No free plan $47 for 48 hours, $229 featured
PitchWall $0 30 days minimum
Three of the five are genuinely free. So this isn't a post about directories being a scam — two of the ones I liked most cost me nothing.
But look at what the free tiers actually are. Free is the queue. Money is the shortcut. Same listing, same audience, the only variable is how long you sit in the hold. Four months is long enough that a product can ship three versions before its listing is allowed to exist.
The joke is that $99 is the cheapest marketing spend most of us will ever make, and we still hesitate — because the pitch was "free" and now it isn't. If they'd said $99 for a 24-hour slot and offered a free four-month lane, nobody would complain.
The part I didn't expect
Being listed turns out to be the easy half.
I also run a directory, so I have the other side of this data. We pulled our full dataset last week: 934 listings, 309,960 listing impressions, 1,523 clicks. 0.49% CTR across the whole thing.
Then we split it by one variable: did the owner ever claim their listing, or was it generated and left alone?
Listings Impressions Clicks CTR
Claimed 311 59,900 1,021 1.70%
Never claimed 623 250,060 502 0.20%
The unclaimed listings got twice the exposure per listing and converted eight times worse. They are two thirds of the directory, they absorb 81% of the impressions, and they return a third of the clicks.
They're not broken. They return 200, they're in the sitemap, they get served. They just don't work. A page nobody has ever looked at is decoration with an indexable URL.
To be fair to the data: "claimed" and "reviewed by a human" are almost the same variable in our set, so I can't tell you claiming causes clicks. My guess is it runs both ways — a founder who claims a listing also writes a better one. The 8x is real; the causal story is a guess.
One thing that surprised me
Across the 298 listings a human actually reviewed, adding the founder's name made no measurable difference to click-through: 1.64% with it, 1.68% without.
Every submission form in this industry insists on that field. In our data it did nothing.
The largest pattern we found among reviewed listings was being an editorial pick — 1.95% vs 1.25%. Which is also the most obviously fixed race: editors pick listings that already look good.
What this changed for me
Only 32% of our listings had ever been reviewed by a person. That's on me.
So we're doing the boring thing: no sitemap entry, no canonical page and no internal link until a human has looked at the listing. If being listed is supposed to mean anything, it has to pass an editor first — otherwise we're one more operation generating pages and calling it a signal.
The short version
Pay attention to whether "free" means free or means "in the queue."
If you do wait out the four months, claim the listing the day it goes live. An unclaimed entry is a wasted entry.
Submit to fewer directories and maintain the ones you're in. The bottleneck was never the number of listings.
Our own queue is at zero today. That says more about how new we are than how good we are — ask me again in three months and I'll tell you what it looks like when it's full.
Disclosure: I run CitableHub, one of the directories in this post. Five is a small sample and I only kept the log for a week — treat it as one person's notes, not a survey. Impressions here are directory impressions, not AI citations. A read is not a recommendation.
Top comments (0)