Savannah Guthrie Says "I Cry Every Morning on the Way to Work" While Her Mother Is Missing: A Therapist on Why the Tears Are the Sanity
There is a specific kind of video that stops your scroll. Not because it is dramatic, but because it is honest. Savannah Guthrie sitting in for Sheinelle Jones on the fourth hour of Today, looking at Jenna Bush Hager, saying the plainest sentence a person can say when the ground has moved. "I can't really even look at you every day without crying."
In a recent Variety piece, Guthrie described what it has been like to keep going to work while her mother, Nancy, is still missing. She cries every morning on the drive in. She cries when a colleague looks at her with too much love. She goes on television anyway.
The internet is doing what the internet does. Some people are calling it brave. Some are calling it too much. Some are quietly wondering how anyone functions at all when a primary attachment figure has vanished from the map.
I am a licensed marriage and family therapist. I have spent seventeen years watching people try to hold themselves together while the deepest bond in the body is threatened. So I want to say something the wellness internet is not going to say, and I want to say it clearly.
The tears are not the breakdown. The tears are the sanity. Savannah crying in the car every morning is not evidence that she is falling apart. It is evidence that she is intact.
The Bridge: Why This Is Not a Story About Coping
Every article you will read this week about Guthrie will use some version of the word cope. How is she coping. How does anyone cope. Tips for coping with ambiguous loss.
I want to move underneath that word, because cope is a fiat concept. It suggests there is a strategy, a technique, a set of behaviors you can bolt on top of a shattered physiology to make you look okay again. That is not what is happening in Guthrie's car. Something older and truer is happening, and it deserves the full clinical picture.
Read the full piece, and join the waitlist for my book, at empathi.com.
What Her Body Is Actually Doing on the Drive to 30 Rock
Here is the frame the wellness internet keeps missing. What Guthrie is experiencing is not a psychological event. It is a biological one.
From the cradle to the grave, human beings need emotional bonding. That is not a poster in a therapist's office. That is mammalian physiology. If a human infant is left on the savanna without a good enough other, a dingo eats it. Your entire body is set up, from breath one, to protest the unavailability of your primary attachment figure. It is hardwired into who we are.
For a small child, the primary attachment figure is the mother. For most adults, that role shifts to the spouse. But for many people, the mother remains the deepest layer of the ledger, the original ground. Guthrie's mother has not been consciously downgraded from that role. She has been the emotional home base for fifty years.
And now that home base is missing. Literally missing. Not distracted, not disappointed, not on a business trip. Gone from the map.
Her limbic system is not treating this as an inconvenience. It is treating it as an existential emergency, because that is the only setting the limbic system has when the primary bond disappears. The tears in the car are cortisol and grief and unanswered attachment protest, all firing at once, all firing correctly.
She is not being dramatic. She is a mammal, doing exactly what mammals do when the bond goes quiet.
The Little Kid in the Kitchen
I use a metaphor in session that fits here almost too well.
A little kid is playing on the kitchen floor with her mom. They are connected. The mother is present. The world is safe. Then the phone rings. Mom picks up. She finds out her sister just died. And in that moment, mom is gone. She is still standing in the kitchen. Her body has not moved. But she is gone.
The little kid is now devastated. Not because anything scary happened to the kid. Because mom, the whole world, the entire settling presence, has vanished from the room while remaining physically present.
Guthrie is living the literal, physical version of that scene. Her mother is not in the kitchen. Her mother is not answering the phone. The presence that has been standing in her body for half a century is not there. Every morning she wakes up and re-registers that fact, and every morning her body does the only correct thing it can do, which is protest.
Two Selves in One Body Going on Television
Here is the part that makes this specific case remarkable. Guthrie is not being asked to grieve in private. She is being asked to grieve while anchoring live television.
In my work I say it constantly. It is never one adult in a hard moment. It is two selves inside one adult body, trying to stay safe in the only ways they once knew. There is the Protector part, the professional, the anchor, the one who reads the teleprompter, holds the segment, keeps the show together. And there is the vulnerable part underneath, the daughter whose mother is missing, the little girl who wants someone to tell her the door is going to open again.
Most people, faced with that much internal load, would collapse one of the two selves. They would either take leave from work entirely and disappear into private grief, or they would armor up completely and refuse to feel anything at all until the workday ends. Both are understandable. Both are common.
What Guthrie is doing is harder and rarer. She is letting both selves exist at once. She is letting the vulnerable one ride shotgun in the car every morning, and she is letting the Protector part take the wheel when the light on the camera turns red. She is not asking one to kill the other.
That is not a coping skill. That is Reflexive Participation. The ability to stay present with your own emotional reality long enough for something new to emerge.
The Three Movements
There is a sequence I walk clients through when the body is on fire and they still have to function in the world. Not to fix the fire. To honor it.
First: know you are affected. Most people skip this step. They go straight to meaning making. Straight to narrative. Straight to strategy. Straight to a plan for how to feel less. Sovereignty begins with the simplest truth. I am affected.
Guthrie said this out loud on network television. "I can't really even look at you every day without crying." That is not weakness on camera. That is step one, executed cleanly, in front of millions of people.
Second: describe how you are affected. This is where language becomes medicine. Not fancy language. Not analytical language. Simple, embodied truth. Where the feeling lives. What it does in the body. Guthrie naming the morning drive, naming the impossibility of looking at a friend without breaking, is that.
Third: feel the affect. Let it move. The feeling itself is not the enemy. It is the gateway. Crying in the car is the third movement. It is not a symptom to be managed. It is the thing itself, doing what it is designed to do.
Why the Culture Wants Her to Stop
We live in a culture that will read her tears as a problem to be solved. Someone, somewhere, is already writing a piece about whether she should take a leave of absence. Someone else is writing about how remarkable it is that she keeps going. Both pieces miss the point.
The Compass of Shame has four directions when pain becomes unbearable. Withdraw. Avoid. Attack self. Attack other. Every one of them is available to Guthrie. She could withdraw into private life until her mother is found or not found. She could avoid, and there is no shortage of avoidance available to a person with money and celebrity, everything from constant work to constant travel to substances to just being too busy to feel. She could attack herself, spiral into all the ways she should have called more, visited more, been more present before this happened. She could attack the searchers, the police, her family members, the world.
None of that is what she is doing. She is refusing the compass. She is letting the vulnerable one be an honored guest in her own body while she still shows up to the job.
That refusal is what I mean when I say the tears are the sanity.
If you want to name your own pattern first, before you go deeper into what any of this is asking of you, you can take the free Figs Quiz.
Why the Tears Are the Proof
Here is the part I most want you to hear if you are reading this while carrying your own version of ambiguous loss. A parent slipping into dementia. A sibling who has stopped speaking to you. A partner who is physically present but emotionally gone. A child who moved across the country and rarely calls. A friend who died too young.
Love hurts because love matters. The measurement of how much your mother mattered to you is not the composure you can perform in her absence. It is the exact volume of the pain her absence produces. If you could not be hurt by her being gone, she would not be your mother in any meaningful sense. She would be a name on a birthday card.
Disconnection is not a flaw in love. It is the proof of it.
I have written more about this in Feeling Emotionally Abandoned by Your Partner, because the biology is the same whether the missing figure is a mother, a spouse, or a child. The bonded body is only ever asking one question underneath the fights and the tears and the sleepless nights: is my person there for me. When the answer keeps coming back no, the body does what a body is built to do.
Read the full piece, and join the waitlist for my book, at empathi.com.
Going Through the River
There is a children's book my kids grew up with. We're Going on a Bear Hunt. Every obstacle, a river, a forest, a snowstorm, meets the same refrain. We can't go over it. We can't go under it. We can't go around it. We have to go through it.
That is the whole clinical picture of what Guthrie is doing on her drive to work. She cannot go over the fact that her mother is missing. She cannot go under it. She cannot go around it with enough productivity or enough performance or enough coffee. She has to go through it. And going through it, in the actual physical body, looks like tears in a car.
This is not something you optimize. This is not something you finish by Tuesday. It is going to take as long as it takes, and the only way out is the whole way through.
What This Means for the Rest of Us
Most people reading this are not on live television and do not have a missing parent making national news. But most people reading this have a version of Guthrie's drive. The commute where the grief comes. The shower where you cry. The five minutes in the parking lot before you go inside and pretend you are okay for the next eight hours.
I want to say two things about that drive.
The first is that the drive is not a problem. It is a sacred space. It is the only place your body has to feel what it needs to feel before you go perform functionality again. Do not try to make it stop. Try to make it welcome.
The second is that going through it does not mean going through it alone. The whole point of a bonded body is that it does not settle by force of will. It settles in the presence of another settled body. That is why Guthrie mentioned Jenna Bush Hager by name. That is why she said she cannot look at her without crying. Because the tears are not just grief. They are also the body finally letting down in the presence of someone safe.
If you are carrying a loss right now and there is no such person in your life, that is the first work. Not fixing the grief. Finding the ground you can land on when the grief comes.
I have written about this in a different frame in the piece on kids affected by parents fighting, because what gets passed down through families is not the fight. It is the body that watched the fight, and the body that learned whether tears in a car are welcome or shameful.
What To Do With Your Own Drive
If you take one thing from this, take this. When the tears come in the car tomorrow morning, do not try to make them stop. Do not put on a podcast to distract yourself. Do not clench your jaw and count the exits.
Notice you are affected. Say out loud, in the car, what you are affected by. Let the feeling move through the body it has been trying to move through all along. Then go to work. Do the segment. Answer the emails. Pick up the kids.
You are not falling apart. You are the exact opposite of falling apart. You are a person whose love is intact enough to still hurt this much, and whose sovereignty is intact enough to keep showing up to your life anyway.
That is not something to fix. That is something to honor.
Read the full piece, and join the waitlist for my book, at empathi.com.
Savannah Guthrie is doing the harder thing on national television. Most of us are doing the harder thing in a parked car, alone, before we walk into a job that will not ask how we are. The tears are not the failure of the system. They are the last honest thing the system knows how to do. Let them come. Then drive.
Top comments (0)