Disarming the Myths of Legal Interpretation: Analysis and Consequences

This article provides an in-depth analysis of eighteen myths of legal interpretation, identified by Maciej Zieliński, providing a precise diagnosis of Polish legal culture. It highlights that, despite a rich theoretical tradition, illusions regarding legal interpretation remain prevalent. These myths are rooted in legal positivism, codification traditions, and bureaucratic formalism, leading to a longing for legal clarity and automatism. The text deconstructs these illusions, revealing the consequences for the quality of legal debate, public trust, and legal education, and compares approaches to legal interpretation across different legal traditions.