re: Teach Writing Code First VIEW POST


My experience learning to code was slightly different than the typical CS program so may not apply directly, but I think has some merit in a certain sense. I went through an electrical and computer engineering program in which computers and software were taught from the ground up - literally. How do computers work? Well switches (transistors) are either on or off, etc. How are those used productively? To do things like add numbers, evaluate logic, etc. Ok, so when I say add these two numbers, I now know exactly what is happening in the machine. This progressively builds up to start learning higher level concepts/abstractions and along the way languages (c to java and so on). You start at the core and grow outward. This ensures you are always building on top of a base foundation of understanding, rather than having to dig through the confusion of lower abstractions. This may or may not apply to many whom never will leave high level languages built for web development, but still may be useful (not a web dev so don't know).

One valuable thing in this approach and maybe in the 'current' approach you mention (depending on how its done), is an understanding without mystery. When the computer spits back error messages at me or does weird things I (generally) understand why because I have working mental models of what the computer does - sure you abstract at certain points (I definitely don't think about transistors or gates), but I have the tools to be more self-reliant. Usually growing outward helps by starting with a smaller domain that a student need's to understand (something you are effectively describing here). In this case it is enforced by the tools rather than arbitrarily. To your boolean operator example, in my case we only had AND and NOT, so you learn the two that exist and then learn how to combine those into more complex operators.

I do completely agree with getting students excited early on in the process. Being able to have successes, no matter how small, is key to being motivated to continue the process. CS and learning to write code is hard, so feeling capable is important. This can be done starting with core concepts at low levels. I wrote a game in assembly my first semester of school. It was crap but I felt accomplished as hell and knew completely how it worked!

Thanks for the article - great read!


That's actually a very good point. Most CS education does not start with hardware so a lot of it does seem like mysticism at first.

I actually learned how computers work at that level (though in my 4th year of college) and I found it very interesting. However, I don't think it's necessary to know for most web development these days. It would be for more advanced computer science work, but most programmers don't work on products that require that kind of programming.

code of conduct - report abuse