DEV Community

GridCircuits
GridCircuits

Posted on

Short Line, Medium Line, Long Line: When the Simple Transmission Model Stops Working

A transmission line is a wire, but it is not always the same kind of problem. A short line and a long line carry power in the same physical way, yet the model that gives a good answer for one can give a misleading answer for the other. The difference is length, and what length does to shunt capacitance.

Why length changes the model

Every kilometre of line has series resistance and series reactance. It also has shunt capacitance to earth and to the other phases. On a short line, that capacitance is small enough to ignore. As the line gets longer, the total capacitance grows, the charging current grows with it, and the line starts to behave differently, especially at light load.

That is why engineers use three rough classes:

  • Short line: roughly under 80 km. Series impedance only.
  • Medium line: roughly 80 to 250 km. Series impedance plus shunt capacitance.
  • Long line: roughly over 250 km. Distributed parameters.

These are rules of thumb, not hard physical boundaries. Voltage level, conductor spacing, and loading also matter. But the length bands are a useful first check: if you are near a boundary, use the more detailed model.

The short line

For a short line, the model is a single series impedance. If R is the resistance per kilometre, X is the reactance per kilometre, and l is the length in kilometres, the total series impedance is:

Z = (R + jX) x l

There is no shunt branch in the model. The sending-end voltage is the receiving-end voltage plus the drop across Z, and the current is the same at both ends. That is simple, and for a short line it is close enough.

In ABCD form, a short line is A = 1, B = Z, C = 0, and D = 1.

The medium line and the nominal pi

For a medium line, shunt capacitance can no longer be ignored. The common way to include it is the nominal pi circuit: the whole series impedance Z in the middle, and half of the total shunt admittance at each end.

If Y is the total shunt admittance of the line, each end gets a shunt branch of:

Y / 2

So the line is drawn as a pi shape: a shunt branch at the sending end, the series impedance across the middle, and a shunt branch at the receiving end. The shunt branches draw charging current even when the load current is small. That is the part the short-line model misses.

In ABCD form, the nominal pi is A = D = 1 + (Z x Y) / 2, B = Z, and C = Y x (1 + (Z x Y) / 4).

The nominal T circuit is the other common lumped model, with half the series impedance on each side of a single central shunt branch. The pi is more often used in practice, and it is the one to reach for first.

The long line and distributed parameters

For a long line, lumping all the capacitance at the ends, or even at the middle, is no longer good enough. The resistance, inductance, and capacitance are spread along the whole length, and voltage and current change continuously along the line.

The long-line model uses the propagation constant gamma and the characteristic impedance Zc. If z is the series impedance per unit length and y is the shunt admittance per unit length, then:

gamma = sqrt(z x y)

Zc = sqrt(z / y)

The ABCD parameters are then:

A = D = cosh(gamma x l)

B = Zc x sinh(gamma x l)

C = sinh(gamma x l) / Zc

Here cosh and sinh are the hyperbolic cosine and sine, and l is the line length. This is the distributed-parameter model. It reduces to the simpler models for short lengths, which is a good check that it is the general case, not a different piece of physics.

Worked illustration: a 100 km line

Take a 100 km line. That is the worked check to do before any calculation.

First, classify it. 100 km is above the roughly 80 km short-line limit and below the roughly 250 km long-line limit, so it is a medium line.

That classification decides the model. A nominal-pi check is the honest minimum here. Start with the total series impedance Z = (R + jX) x 100, work out the total shunt admittance Y for 100 km, and put Y / 2 at each end.

Now compare that with the short-line shortcut. If you use series impedance only for this 100 km line, you leave out both shunt branches. That means you leave out the charging current they draw. Your calculated current will be too low, and you will miss part of the receiving-end voltage rise that appears at light load.

That voltage rise is the Ferranti effect in general terms: on a lightly loaded line, the charging current flowing through the series reactance can make the receiving-end voltage higher than the sending-end voltage. A series-only model cannot show it properly, because it has no charging current to work with. The nominal pi can, because the shunt branches are in the circuit.

The point is not that the nominal pi is exact for 100 km. It is a lumped approximation, and a long-line calculation would be more accurate still. The point is that it is the minimum model that includes the effect that matters at this length. Using anything simpler understates the charging current and the voltage rise, and that is an error in the direction that matters for insulation, voltage control, and reactive power planning.

A quick rule to remember

  • Under about 80 km: try the series-impedance model first, and check that capacitance really is small.
  • From about 80 to 250 km: use the nominal pi, with Y / 2 at each end.
  • Over about 250 km: use the distributed-parameter model, with cosh and sinh of gamma x l.

When in doubt, step up one model and see how much the answer moves. If it barely moves, the simpler model was fine. If it moves a lot, the simpler model was hiding something.

Try it yourself

Try the numbers for a line of your own with the free GridCircuits transmission line calculator, which shows its formula and runs in the browser with no signup or upload. Put in a length near 100 km, run the nominal-pi check, and then compare it with the series-only result to see how much the charging current and receiving-end voltage change.

Top comments (0)