A substation bus can sound abstract until you picture it as a loop. That is the simplest way to think about a ring bus: a set of circuit positions joined end to end, so power can travel around the ring in either direction. The question that makes the arrangement interesting is not what happens when everything is closed. It is what happens when a breaker opens — and, more importantly, what happens when a second one opens.
Six positions, six breakers
The arrangement in this example has six circuit positions, linked by six breakers, B1 to B6. B1 connects positions 1 and 2, B2 connects positions 2 and 3, B3 connects positions 3 and 4, B4 connects positions 4 and 5, B5 connects positions 5 and 6, and B6 connects positions 6 and 1. That last link is the one that closes the loop. Without it, you would have a line. With it, you have a ring.
Incoming circuits enter at positions 1 and 4. Demands sit at positions 2, 3, 5 and 6. In other words, the two places where power comes in are opposite each other around the ring, and the four places where power is used sit between them. That spacing matters when we start opening breakers, because where a demand sits relative to an incoming circuit decides whether it can still be reached.
When everything is closed
With all breakers closed, the ring is one electrical bus. It does not mean the six positions have disappeared. It means that, electrically, they are joined together into a single bus, so the ring behaves as one connected whole. If you are tracing a path from an incoming circuit to a demand, there is a connected path in both directions, and the whole ring shares the same bus result.
That is also why a closed breaker is treated in this model as an ideal connection. A closed breaker merges the positions it joins, and the merged positions are treated as one electrical bus. That simplification has a limit that is easy to miss: the per-breaker current split cannot be obtained from a merged-bus model. Once positions are merged, the model no longer keeps the separate breaker-by-breaker currents a reader might hope to read off.
Opening one breaker
Opening one breaker normally still leaves a connected path. Opening one of the six breakers leaves the other five closed, and those five still provide a connected path around the ring. The ring is no longer a closed loop, but it is still connected. That is the normal, reassuring case, and it is also the reason a single opening can look uneventful.
Opening two breakers
Opening two can split the bus into separately supplied sections. With two breaks in the loop, the remaining closed breakers no longer join everything into one bus. Instead, the ring can fall into separate sections, each supplied through its own path. Which sections form depends on which two breakers are open, because the open breakers decide where the ring is cut. Two openings close together cut off a short stretch between them. Two openings farther apart divide the ring into two longer stretches. Either way, the bus is no longer one electrical bus, and each section has to be understood on its own.
A section with no source path is an island, and no solved result should be shown for it. If a section is cut off from both incoming circuits, at positions 1 and 4, it has no source to supply its demands. Showing a voltage or a flow for it anyway would give the impression that the section had been solved, when there is nothing to solve from. The honest result is to show no solved result for that island.
A worked example
Take the calculator's default example at 230 kV. There are four demands of 25 MW / 8 MVAr each, a 100 MVA base, and two identical incoming impedances of 0.01 + j0.10 p.u. With the full ring closed, the ring voltage is approximately 1.018 p.u. at about -2.62 degrees, total active loss is about 0.53 MW, and each incoming circuit supplies approximately 129 A at the source end.
Now open B2 and B5. That forms two separately supplied sections. Each section still has a source path, so each can be understood as a section supplied on its own, rather than as part of one bus. Open B1 and B2 instead, and the picture is different: position 2 is isolated as a source-disconnected island. It sits between the two open breakers, with no source path, so no solved result should be shown for it. The contrast between those two pairs is the whole lesson in miniature: the same number of open breakers, two, can leave sections supplied — or leave a position islanded — depending on which breakers they are.
What to take away
Count the openings, and then ask where they are. One open breaker normally still leaves a connected path. Two can split the bus into separately supplied sections, and a section with no source path is an island, with no solved result to show. Keep the ideal-breaker limit in mind too: closed breakers merge positions into one bus, so a per-breaker current split cannot be obtained from a merged-bus model. If you want to try the numbers yourself, the ring-bus load-flow calculator lets you open and close B1 to B6 and see how the sections change.
Top comments (0)