My Shame

jacoby profile image Dave Jacoby Originally published at jacoby.github.io on ・2 min read

My Shame

I tweeted this, saying “my shame”.

In the beginning there was format_all_that_data. It was an internal function that took a big data structure and turned it into HTML.

Using Perl’s CGI.pm to create the HTML. I knew this was a bad idea a decade before, but it was the lab style, and it took a while before I understood Template Toolkit (and other templating engines) as the way of the future.

I needed to make changes, but I had to work in production (a situation I still have yet to escape) and wanted to keep the old one working, so I called it format_all_that_data_new , and when it was done, I changed the places I knew used format_all_that_data to format_all_that_data_new and made it so that format_all_that_data returned an empty string. That way, if output was expected but not forthcoming, someone would tell me.

And then I was asked to do a few small changes. One change would be fine; do it, test it, release it, forget it. But there were more changes, which is enough to dive onto templating and fixing a lot of other stuff in that program. And again, I am developing in production, so I create format_all_that_data_tt , which uses Template Toolkit to do the HTML correctly.

And, once I have it, I want to switch over, but I want to minimize the changes, so I move format_all_that_data_new to format_all_that_data_old , so that it and all the knowledge I stuck into it and fear to remove are there but not gone.

So I rewrote format_all_that_data_new to, in it’s entirety:

sub format_all_that_data_new($data) { format_all_that_data_tt($data) }

I keep dead code because I fear, and add cruft to route around it.

This is my shame.

If you have any questions or comments, I would be glad to hear it. Ask me on Twitter or make an issue on my blog repo.

Posted on by:

jacoby profile

Dave Jacoby


Long time computer user. Long time programmer.


Editor guide