A courtesy copy is a duplicate sent straight to a judge's chambers. The rules live in standing orders, courtroom procedures and local rules. They change by judge, by filing type and by hearing stage. We built a count of where the database shows one. Here is how we did it.
The unit and the population
The unit is a judge-court entry. That is the database judge row inside its court listing. It is not a unique person. A judge who sits in several counties can appear more than once. An entry can carry a predecessor's standing order or an adopted court policy reproduced on the current page.
We read the production database on October 22, 2026. Every request was an HTTP GET that translates to a SELECT. No write or RPC ran. The eligible population includes active, non-retired entries with at least one current rule-bearing source of their own. We excluded the synthetic court owner, records typed as court, inactive entries, the California statewide rulebook and merged-court redirect stubs. That leaves 2,257 entries with their own documents.
The fields we searched
The structured type is CourtesyCopyRule. The useful fields are trigger, requirement.copies, requirement.delivery_timing, requirement.delivery_method, requirement.formatting, exemptions and prohibitions. Delivery methods include email and physical channels. A prohibition can cover only one channel.
The candidate query unions two predicates by rule ID. One matches the structured logic type. The other uses a regex over the source text for terms such as courtesy, working copy, chambers copy, paper copy and hard copy. The joins run from court to judge, judge to source, source to version and version to rule. The builder matches the newest active version for each source.
The review step
The search over-selects. A passage can mention a courtesy copy in a heading or in a service instruction. We read a short excerpt for each candidate and rejected false matches. A positive label requires at least one accepted passage.
- For
paper_required_evidence, a reviewed passage must require a paper, hard or physical duplicate, or a printed binder for a stated submission. Conditional duties count, such as long filings or hearing materials. -
email_route_evidenceapplies to a reviewed passage that permits or directs sending the court or chambers a duplicate by email. Proposed orders and advance hearing materials qualify. Email can be an alternative or an added requirement. - A reviewed passage counts as
copy_waiver_evidencewhen it expressly says copies are unnecessary or forbidden for a stated class, stage or threshold. This is scoped. It never means the entry requires no copies in every case.
The flags overlap. An entry can require paper and email for the same filing. A waiver for short filings can sit beside a paper requirement for longer ones. The headline takes each label separately and does not add the overlapping counts together.
What the numbers mean
Paper-copy requirements appear in material linked to 193 of the 2,257 entries. Email routes appear in 220. An express waiver or prohibition appears in 212. The Southern District of New York shows 22 of its 64 entries with paper evidence. These are lower bounds.
A zero flag means no accepted evidence in the reviewed selection. It does not mean no rule. The search produces more passages than the reviewed set. Unreviewed material remains unknown. Material omitted by extraction or unreadable OCR can also be missed. Treat the counts as a floor and read the linked source before you file.
The CSV keeps the flags, quotes, source links and denominators. The full method and the per-court counts are on the data page: https://www.courtrules.app/data/courtesy-copies?ref=devto&utm_source=devto&utm_medium=post&utm_campaign=brand
Top comments (0)