DEV Community

Discussion on: Spam sucks

Collapse
 
jamesrweb profile image
James Robb • Edited

Captcha is the devil for accessibility so never ever add captcha anywhere... ever. There’s other ways to validate without bombing your application accessibility for users with access needs.

Otherwise good points overall.

Thread Thread
 
crimsonmed profile image
Médéric Burlet

I disagree totally there are now invisible captcha for example 😊

Thread Thread
 
jamesrweb profile image
James Robb

Which is inaccessible too.

Captcha is always in the top 10 issues users with access needs bring up, doesn’t matter the type of captcha. Captcha in its current form is a problem and not a solution. The users have spoken 🤷‍♂️

Thread Thread
 
crimsonmed profile image
Médéric Burlet

really? We have it on 13 of our commercial solutions and never had an issue with it so :/
let's agree to disagree.

Thread Thread
 
jamesrweb profile image
James Robb • Edited

“Pages with ReCAPTCHA had 12.6 more [accessibility] errors on average than those without.” - Web Aim 1,000,000

Captcha has improved, but it’s not accessible to all users yet or even a plurality. Issues remain. Old versions in the wild. Etc.

There are valid captcha alternatives which solve many of captchas (all versions) issues but still captcha has improved as I said, it’s just not all the way there for users with access needs or those with privacy concerns.