DEV Community

Key Ledgers
Key Ledgers

Posted on

How disputed numbers get checked, in six steps

Many money disputes come down to one question: what are the numbers meant to prove? This walkthrough follows a forensic accountant through six steps, from that question to the findings. If you have ever reconciled two datasets, much of it will look familiar. It is general guidance for England and Wales, not legal advice. A forensic accountant works on financial questions only. Legal advice is outside the role.

Step 1: Fix the question

Every check depends on the question, so write it down first. The accountant needs to know which transactions, balances or calculations are in dispute and which records can answer the point. A request to look at the accounts and give an opinion leaves nothing to test. A better question has clear limits, such as dates and a comparison. How much profit did the claimant lose in the six months after a flood, measured against the three years before?

If the question is loose, the expert has to choose an interpretation. A party may later argue that the expert answered a different question from the one the case needed. Put the facts the accountant should take as given beside the question. The date a breach happened is a typical example. Written assumptions mark the edge of the report. Without them the expert may have to make factual findings, and those are for the court to decide.

Step 2: Build the evidence log and note the gaps

Next, list the records that have been provided. Start with bank statements, tax returns, management accounts and the accounts filed. Payroll runs, VAT returns and lists of what customers owe and what the business owes may also matter. Complex matters can need transaction data exported from the accounting software. Evidence already in the case, such as a divorce financial statement or a prosecution schedule, goes on the list too.

Good practice is to number every document as it arrives. Here is one way to lay out the schedule:

Ref Document Period covered Source What it supports Gaps noted
1 Bank statements Jan to Dec 2023 Bank Cash movements March missing
2 Management accounts Year to 31 Dec 2023 Company Reported profit No workings
3 Ledger export (record of entries) Year to 31 Dec 2023 Accounting software Account balances Unmatched entries

The rows are examples only. In a civil case the report must state the substance of all material instructions, written or oral. Rule 35.10(3) of the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) requires this. A separate note of anything the expert was told orally or at a meeting makes that easier.

Gaps are best found early. Where papers are missing, the accountant records the gap and advises which documents to request. In civil proceedings that request can go through disclosure, which is usually the stage where each side hands over its documents. An accountant instructed as an expert cannot compel anyone to produce them.

Step 3: Reconcile the ledgers to the bank

A ledger is the book of account in which a business records its transactions. Reconciling means matching one record to another. Each ledger is matched to the underlying bank and transaction records. The aim is to find any reported balance that the records cannot back up.

Suppose two connected companies each record a different balance on the same loan. Both ledgers are checked against the bank records, and the check shows where they diverge. This is a made-up example, not a client case.

Step 4: Trace the money

Relevant entries are followed through connected companies, which is tracing in the accounting sense. The result can be a transaction analysis or a chronology: a plain account of where the money went and what shows it. Complex corporate structures make the tracing harder.

Records are sometimes disputed or incomplete. Then the accountant looks for secondary sources that can fill the gaps.

Step 5: Test the calculations

Calculations are tested against the source records, whoever prepared them. That covers the accountant's own workings and a schedule produced by another accountant. The records, the assumptions and the arithmetic all get reviewed. The findings then explain where the evidence supports the figure and where it does not.

Step 6: Separate proof from gaps and assumptions

Each calculation should trace back to a source document or to a named assumption. Assumptions are justified in writing, and gaps are listed. That shows which parts of a figure are documented and which rest on judgement.

Match the checks to the dispute

The steps stay the same, but the records and the questions change with the dispute.

Dispute Records that matter most What gets checked
Business value in divorce finance Accounts, director's loan accounts and the transactions behind them Sustainable income, loan account movements, unexplained transactions
Business interruption claim (civil) Trading records before the event Comparison period, trend, gross profit margin, added costs
HMRC investigation (tax) The taxpayer's underlying records Whether the declared position can be rebuilt, and the basis of any additional assessment
Confiscation (criminal, Proceeds of Crime Act 2002) The prosecution's financial schedule Benefit and available amount (the order follows the lower figure), and any tainted gifts
Insolvency (civil) Transactions before the insolvency Pre-insolvency payments a lawyer may challenge, such as preferences (payments that favoured one creditor), and records for claims against directors

Where one party controls the records, the other side cannot check them alone. The accountant looks for inconsistencies in what exists.

HMRC uses Code of Practice 9 in selected cases of suspected tax fraud. In those cases an accountant can be involved from the outset of the Contractual Disclosure Facility. That is HMRC's process, not court disclosure. Crown Court confiscation is a criminal matter, so different rules apply to expert evidence there.

Two common calculations

Income that spending does not match

In divorce finance cases, property purchases, school fees, holidays or cars may look large against the declared income. This back-calculation is called lifestyle analysis. A careful estimate should allow for other sources of money.

Loss that has to be calculated

In a business interruption claim, disputes often turn on four points. They are the period used for comparison, the adjustment for trend in earlier turnover, the gross profit margin and the increased costs of working. The method compares what actually happened with what would have happened without the event. A personal injury claim brings a different problem. A self-employed claimant may have no payslips, so the accounts for the period before the accident are the starting point.

What the work produces

The output depends on the instruction and may include reconciled schedules, a transaction analysis, written findings or an expert report. Everyone agrees the scope before the work begins.

If the work becomes expert evidence in a civil case, Part 35 of the CPR generally applies. CPR 35.3 makes helping the court the expert's overriding duty, and that duty overrides any obligation to whoever pays for the work. Under Practice Direction 35 the report should be addressed to the court, not to the party that instructed the expert. A statement of truth in the prescribed form, signed by the expert, verifies it.

Expert evidence in family proceedings follows Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules. In criminal proceedings it follows Part 19 of the Criminal Procedure Rules. Tax tribunals and arbitrations have their own rules. Check which set of rules applies before the work starts.

What a good civil report shows

Each answer below should be yes when a civil report arrives:

  • Does it list the expert's qualifications and the material relied on?
  • Does it state the facts the expert was asked to assume?
  • Does it set out the substance of the material instructions, written or oral?
  • Does it report a range of opinion where one exists, with a summary of conclusions?
  • Does it deal with facts that hurt the instructing party?
  • Does it carry a statement of truth?
  • Does it end by confirming that the expert understands and has complied with the duty to the court?

If the expert's view changes on a material matter after the report, every party should be told without delay and, where appropriate, the court. A report that leaves out a required element can be challenged.

When two experts' numbers differ

In a civil case each side may have its own expert if the court gives permission. In practice the reports are often exchanged on the same day, so neither side sees the other's first. A civil court can then direct a discussion between the experts under CPR 35.12. Neither the parties nor their lawyers attend unless the court orders it or all parties and the experts agree. The discussion exists to agree and narrow issues, not to settle the case.

After the discussion the experts prepare a joint statement. Under Practice Direction 35 they sign at the end of the discussion, or as soon as practicable and within 7 days. Copies go to the parties within 14 days of signing. The statement lists the points of agreement and disagreement, with brief reasons, and explains any significant change of view. A well-kept evidence log helps here, because each disputed figure can be traced to the documents behind it.

When it is not an accounting question

Some questions belong with another specialist. If the only issue is whether one payment left an account on one day, the bank statement may settle it. A pension that promises a set income, known as a defined benefit scheme, needs an actuary. In a divorce the accountant can flag it but cannot value it. Intellectual property may need an IP valuer, and land may need a surveyor qualified through the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS). A regulatory question may fit a compliance specialist better. Expert help is needed where the court cannot read the financial information without specialist skill.

Two habits that slow the work

  • A late start. In a civil claim, an accountant instructed after disclosure lists have been served may find that records were never disclosed. Obtaining them can mean going back to the court. The Case Management Conference is the hearing where the court sets the timetable. Bringing the accountant in by then, or earlier, lets the accountant say what to request while disclosure is still open.
  • A one-sided briefing. If the instructing party's view is the only view the expert hears, the report may lean towards it. That sits badly with the duty to the court. A fair letter of instruction records disputed facts as disputes.

Before you send papers to the accountant

  • Is the question written down, with clear limits such as dates and a comparison?
  • Is every document numbered, with its period and source?
  • Have the assumptions been listed apart from the facts?
  • Can each balance be traced to a bank or transaction record?
  • Is the set complete enough to start, with any missing items listed?

Incomplete papers are a frequent cause of delay, because each extra request adds to the timetable. A hurried instruction gives the accountant less time, so confirm the court deadline early.

Written by Key Ledgers Forensic Accountants Limited, a forensic accounting firm in England and Wales. Its forensic accounting service page has more detail.

Top comments (0)