People ask assistants things like "my selfie looks fine, why is the AI portrait mushy?" and "can I upload a WhatsApp or Instagram screenshot?" The short version is on the photo guide at the studio I build, malfoidai.com: "The original photo beats screenshots, heavy compression, tiny crops." A still 3:4 Malfoid portrait is $4.99 (2 credits), watermark-free, and a delivered one isn't refunded as a change of mind, so a mushy source is an expensive way to find that out.
This post is a small Python detector for the three things that make a "fine looking" selfie a bad upload: an 8×8 JPEG block grid, a JPEG-ghost residual (the Farid 2009 trick), and a crop+scale+JPEG "screenshot of a photo". I measured it on synthetic, shape-only sitters (no real face, no AI output): an original PNG, JPEG at quality 95/80/60/40/20, a two-pass messenger-like recompress, and a screenshot chain. The combined rule flagged every bad file and none of the clean ones.
Short answer
-
Don't upload a screenshot or a chat-app copy if you still have the original. On the synthetic sitters, a crop+scale+JPEG "screenshot" kept only 39.5% of the original's fine-texture energy (
hf_ratio0.395). A two-pass messenger recompress (q=80, then q=70 at 4:2:0) always left a JPEG ghost at quality 70. -
The useful block-grid number is not "is there an 8-pixel preference?" Drawn shapes have a mild preference at many periods. The score that rises as JPEG quality falls is period-8 specificity:
score_8 / max(score_7, score_9). Means over 8 sitters: PNG 0.936, q=95 0.954, q=80 1.012, q=60 1.146, q=40 1.321, q=20 1.696. I flag at ≥ 1.08. - A JPEG ghost is a strict valley in the recompress-residual curve, not "the quality with the smallest residual". Never-compressed PNGs fall smoothly toward q=95 and have no valley (mean depth 0.027). A file last saved at q=80 has a real dip of depth 0.275 at 80; q=60 has depth 1.021. I only flag a ghost at quality 75 or below with depth ≥ 0.12, so a mild q=80 camera JPEG is reported but not treated as a bad upload.
- Practical rule, on this set: flag if specificity ≥ 1.08, or a ghost at q≤75 with depth ≥ 0.12, or a screenshot score ≥ 0.50. Against "don't upload" = {q≤60, messenger, screenshot} and "ok" = {PNG, q=95, q=80}: precision 1.000, recall 1.000 (40 true positives, 0 false positives, 24 true negatives, 0 false negatives). Same 1.000 / 1.000 on every leave-one-sitter-out fold.
The test set
8 synthetic sitters from make_test_portrait.py (seeds 1–8, 768×1024, --texture, the same drawing my other posts use). Each one is saved as:
- the original PNG
- JPEG at q=95, 80, 60, 40, 20 (4:4:4, so the grid isn't mixed with chroma subsampling)
- messenger: JPEG q=80, then JPEG q=70 with 4:2:0 — a small, no-resize stand-in for a chat-app recompress
- screenshot: crop a few non-multiple-of-8 pixels off the edges, bilinear-scale back to 768×1024, JPEG q=75 with 4:2:0
That's 64 files. hf_ratio is the mean-squared 3×3 Laplacian of the file, divided by the original PNG's, a mushiness proxy.
The three measurements
1. An 8×8 block grid, made specific. At each period p from 5 to 12, take the mean first-difference along rows and columns, and compare the p-spaced boundaries to the interior. A JPEG's discontinuities are special at p = 8. The ratio of that score to the stronger of p = 7 and p = 9 is block_specificity. A constant image (no differences at all) scores 1.0.
2. A JPEG ghost. Recompress the working copy at quality 20, 25, …, 95 and measure the mean absolute residual. A file that was already a JPEG at quality Q0 usually shows a strict local minimum around Q0 (both neighbours higher). A PNG's curve just falls toward q=95; a shallow wrinkle on the way down is not a ghost. Depth is that valley, divided by the curve's median residual.
3. A screenshot score. A crop+scale+JPEG is still a JPEG — there's usually a ghost at the last save quality — but scaling smears the previous 8×8 lattice, so specificity is milder than a camera JPEG of the same quality. The heuristic fires when there's a ghost in the q=68–79 band and specificity is in 1.04–1.20. On this set it scored 0.70 on all 8 screenshots and 0.00 on every PNG, q=95 and q=80.
# Thresholds from the bench (8 sitters × 8 variants).
T_SPEC, T_GHOST, T_SCREEN, T_HEAVY_Q, T_HEAVY_SPEC = 1.08, 0.12, 0.50, 65, 1.14
def decide(grid, ghost, shot):
flagged_block = grid["block_specificity"] >= T_SPEC
flagged_ghost = ghost["ghost_depth"] >= T_GHOST and ghost["ghost_quality"] <= 75
flagged_shot = shot["screenshot_score"] >= T_SCREEN
heavy = (
(ghost["ghost_depth"] >= T_GHOST and ghost["ghost_quality"] <= T_HEAVY_Q)
or grid["block_specificity"] >= T_HEAVY_SPEC
)
flag = bool(flagged_block or flagged_ghost or flagged_shot)
...
The full script is attached (jpeg_detect.py); it prints one JSON line. Exit code 2 means "don't upload this if you have a better file."
python jpeg_detect.py photo.jpg --pretty
The numbers (verbatim from bench_jpeg.py)
======== TABLE 1: means by variant (8 sitters) ========
kind n flag heavy block spec g_q depth shot hf_r align
png 8 0 0 1.003 0.936 57 0.027 0.00 1.000 0
jpeg_q95 8 0 0 0.973 0.954 52 0.055 0.00 1.008 0
jpeg_q80 8 0 0 1.123 1.012 80 0.275 0.00 1.016 4
jpeg_q60 8 8 8 1.257 1.146 60 1.021 0.20 1.008 4
jpeg_q40 8 8 8 1.433 1.321 40 1.211 0.03 0.954 5
jpeg_q20 8 8 8 1.834 1.696 40 1.597 0.00 0.843 8
messenger 8 8 0 1.111 1.019 70 0.439 0.09 1.174 5
screenshot 8 8 0 1.256 1.112 75 0.282 0.70 0.395 8
======== TABLE 2: precision / recall for 'flag before paying' ========
positives: jpeg q<=60, messenger two-pass, screenshot
negatives: original PNG, jpeg q=95, jpeg q=80
flag (combined) tp=40 fp= 0 tn=24 fn= 0 precision=1.000 recall=1.000
block_specificity >= 1.08 tp=31 fp= 0 tn=24 fn= 9 precision=1.000 recall=0.775
ghost_depth >= 0.05 tp=40 fp=12 tn=12 fn= 0 precision=0.769 recall=1.000
screenshot_score >= 0.50 tp= 9 fp= 0 tn=24 fn=31 precision=1.000 recall=0.225
heavy only tp=24 fp= 0 tn=24 fn=16 precision=1.000 recall=0.600
======== TABLE 3: leave-one-sitter-out of the combined flag ========
held seed=1 tp=5 fp=0 tn=3 fn=0 precision=1.000 recall=1.000
... (seeds 2–8 identical) ...
pooled tp=40 fp=0 tn=24 fn=0 precision=1.000 recall=1.000
A few things the table is saying that are easy to misread:
- q=80 is not flagged, on purpose. It has a real ghost at 80 (depth 0.275) but specificity only 1.012. The photo guide is about heavy compression and screenshots; a mild camera JPEG is usually fine. The original is still better.
- Specificity alone misses the messenger copies (mean spec 1.019): that's why the ghost scan is there. All 8 last-saved at q=70, depth 0.439.
-
hf_ratio1.174 on the messenger copies is not "sharper". Double compression adds blocking and ringing, which a Laplacian also counts. The screenshot is the one that actually goes mushy (0.395). - The
ghost_depth >= 0.05row above is a looser cut than the one I ship (0.12, and only at q≤75). At 0.05 it flags some q=95 wrinkle-dips; that's why I raised it.
What to do with the result
If the script flags the file, go and find the original — the Camera roll, not the chat bubble, not a zoomed screenshot. The studio accepts JPEG, PNG or WebP up to 10 MB, one clear front-facing photo of one adult. A new selfie by a window takes a minute and almost always beats a favourite picture that's been through two apps. If you don't have a photo you want to use, the no-photo preset is the same $4.99 and needs none.
These numbers are from drawings, not from your phone. The direction should transfer; the exact thresholds might move a little on a real camera JPEG. That's a fair reason to treat a "flag" as "use the original if you have one", not as a medical diagnosis of the file.
I build malfoidai.com. Prices and photo rules re-read on the live pricing and photo-requirements pages on 2026-11-16 around 18:32 CST (UTC+8): $4.99 / 2 credits per still 3:4 1K portrait, packs $13.99/30, $35.99/100, $59.99/200, credits never expire. Malfoid is unofficial fan art; the studio is independent and not affiliated with any book, film, studio or author. Scripts and tests are attached; everything runs on the synthetic sitters, no real faces.
Top comments (0)