DEV Community

Discussion on: Github Must Be a Free Platform

Collapse
 
nekofar profile image
Milad Nekofar

In an ideal world, decentralization would be the best solution.
But as how as you know, GitHub is not a simple Git hosting these days.

Collapse
 
kungtotte profile image
Thomas Landin

All of the options I mentioned offer everything github does, and they're all open source too and you can self host them.

I know github isn't just git, but we don't need github to do exactly what we are doing today.

Thread Thread
 
knownasilya profile image
Ilya Radchenko

None of the solutions mentioned are decentralized. Git is decentralized but those services are not, even if self hosted. There are very early projects like codeonchain.network/ and others starting out that are.

Thread Thread
 
kungtotte profile image
Thomas Landin

Different instances of X can replicate between each other, so you're not siloing your development, and by decentralisation I was referring more to the fact that not all open source development has to happen on a single platform.

It's OK if some projects are on GitLab, some on Gitea, and others on Sourcehut.

True decentralisation can be a worthwhile goal down the road, but right now we can solve the problem using the tools we already have.

Thread Thread
 
knownasilya profile image
Ilya Radchenko

Then we agree 😄