Discussion on: Classes in JS: Public, Private and Protected

[Obscerno]

This is my crack at the problem. I think this works back to es3 but I'm not sure?

// Declare objects within an anonymous function to limit access.
var objectRefs = (function() {
  // This is the object we want to inherit from.
  function Base(param1, _protected) {
    var _public = this;
    var _protected = _protected || {};
    var _private = {};

    // Declare some variables
    _public.shared = "Anyone can access this!";
    _protected.inherited = "This is protected";
    _private.secretVar = "Children cannot access this.";

    // Let's try a few functions.
    _public.foo = function() {
      // We can access protected and private functions here. This would
      // not be possible if we attached it to the prototype.
      console.log(_protected.inherited);
      console.log(_private.secretVar);
      _private.secret();
    };

    _protected.bar = function() {
      // One thing to watch out for: private functions called after
      // construction do NOT have access to the object via 'this'. This is
      // masked by the fact that I assigned it to the '_public' var.
      // More reading: https://stackoverflow.com/q/20279484/3658757
      console.log(_public.shared);
    };

    _private.secret = function() {
      // The same warning in _protected.bar applies here too.
      console.log(_public.shared);
    };
  }

  // Inherits from Base
  function Derived(param1, _protected) {
    var _public = this;
    var _protected = _protected || {};
    var _private = {};

    // Inherit (ready for the magic?)
    Base.call(this, param1, _protected);

    // Since we passed a reference to the "_protected" object as an argument
    // to the Base object, it has been attaching all of its protected
    // variables to it. We can now access those variables here:

    // Outputs "This is protected"
    console.log(_protected.inherited);

    // We can also access protected functions:
    _protected.bar();

    // We can even override protected variables and functions.
    _protected.inherited = "New value!";

    // We cannot access private variables belonging to Base.
    // This fails:
    // console.log(_private.secretVar);
  }

  // We don't want to allow public access to the constructors, because this
  // would let outside code pass in a '_protected' var. Instead, we create new
  // objects that accept all params minus '_protected', and inherit from the
  // target object.
  return {
    Base: function(param1) {
      Base.call(this, param1);
    },
    Derived: function(param1) {
      Derived.call(this, param1);
    }
  };
}());

// Assign the constructors to variables for clarity.
var Base = objectRefs.Base;
var Derived = objectRefs.Derived;

// This is how you construct the object.
var newDerived = new Derived("param1");

// Public functions are accessible.
newDerived.foo();

// Protected functions are not. These fail:
// newDerived.bar();
// newDerived.protected.bar();

[Lukas Gaucas]

Seems very promising. Now examining the code! :O

[Obscerno]

Have fun! I'd like to add that in practice I'd probably not go to these length to protect the variables unless it was absolutely necessary. I'd probably do something more like:

// This is the object we want to inherit from.
function Base(param1, _) {
    var _this = this;
    var shared = _ || {};

    // Declare class variables and functions like this:
    this.foo = "Anyone can access this!";

    shared.bar = function() {
        console.log(secret());
        return "Shared function accessed!";
    };

    var secret = function() {
        // _this is needed to access object in private functions, otherwise leave out.
        return _this.foo;
    };
}

// Inherits from Base
function Derived(param1) {
    // Inherit
    var shared = {};
    Base.call(this, param1, shared);

    // Outputs "Shared function accessed!"
    console.log(shared.bar());
}

// Exclude shared param when not inheriting.
var myBase = new Base("param1");
var myDerived = new Derived("param1");

Yo use it the same, you just have to trust people not to pass in a _ argument on construction to snatch the shared variables. I think it's a step up from defining public variables like this._myProtectedVar, but it's not technically protected (which is why I call the variable shared inside the function).