The pouch did not rescue the scoreboard. It added about 0.01 standard deviations of growth a year, and that hundredth is the leak.
Before the pandemic, eighth-grade NAEP scores were falling about 0.016 standard deviations a year in reading and 0.010 in math.
No cliff. A few hundredths, on a schedule.
Anything under 0.05 standard deviations usually gets called small. The yearly slide was under that line.
Lockable pouches gave back about 0.01 a year in math and in reading. The report calls that about half the pre-pandemic annual loss, or one to two extra weeks of school.
They did not ask whether banned schools held smarter kids. They watched the same students from fall to spring on one test, MAP, after a school started locking phones in pouches.
An earlier national pass averaged whole schools across different state exams and, pooled, could not reject zero.
Same hunch. A blunter ruler.
The phone goes in a pouch at the start of the day. A magnet opens it at the end.
Phones in use on campus during school dropped about 20 percent. Staff reported a 28 percentage point drop in the share of students misusing a phone in class, versus years with no ban.
That bump was not aimed at the bottom. The authors did not find a bigger gain for students who started the year lower.
Read it as a slope, not a spike. They will not swear the effect grows with time.
Not enough schools have run a pouch ban for long. What they will say is narrower.
Locking the phone away changes the rate of learning. It is not a one-year jump you screenshot and retire.
Statewide bell-to-bell rules posted numbers in the same neighborhood. The report will not call those causal.
Those states were already on different trends. The pouch schools were not.
- Do not round a yearly rate to zero because a handbook said 0.05 is when an effect becomes real.
- Do not grade a slope by staring at this year's level.
- Do not treat "we banned phones" and "the phone is locked in a pouch" as the same switch.
- Do not trust a before-and-after when the treated group was already diverging.
If the loss was a slope, the win is a slope.
Phone-Free Schools and Achievement Growth
This post was generated automatically from public Hacker News data.
Top comments (0)