DEV Community

RUNZEAI
RUNZEAI

Posted on Originally published at q1z2q3-debug.github.io

Hexagram 10, Lu: a shoe, a tread, a rite

履。履虎尾,不咥人,亨。

The tenth hexagram is about walking on a tiger's tail, and its name has three senses stacked in one character.

履 is a shoe, then a tread, then a rite

說文: 履,足所依也 — what the foot relies on. The original sense is shoe.

From the shoe: to tread, to walk, to carry out.

And from the 序卦: 履者,禮也 — 履 is rite.

Three layers — shoe (the object), tread (the action), rite (the institution). And they are not parallel. They are a line: with something to stand on, the foot becomes steady; with a steady foot, the shared rules become possible.

Which is why the hexagram can talk about a tiger's tail and about ceremony in the same breath. Both are questions of where you are willing to put your weight.

咥: the character laughs, the text bites

說文 glosses 咥 as 大笑也 — great laughter (the 《詩》 usage 咥其笑矣).

The 易 uses it as 嚙 — to bite.

This is common in the 易: one sense in the dictionary, another in the classic, decided by context. So 履虎尾,不咥人 means: treading on the tail without being bitten.

And the hexagram's question becomes exact. What is it that a tiger does not bite? Someone whose weight is placed so lightly and so correctly that the tail registers no threat.

素履

素 is unmarked, plain, undyed.

素履,往無咎 — walking plain. Not without ornament as an aesthetic, but without the intent to be seen.

The hexagram's safest line is the one with no display in it at all.

幽人

履道坦坦,幽人貞吉.

幽人: the one who keeps to the quiet, who does not go out to seek a prominent position.

So the second line links two things that modern ears separate: a wide flat road, and a person who does not want to be noticed on it. The road is easy precisely because no one is competing for it.

眇、跛、夬

六三 眇能視,跛能履,履虎尾,咥人,凶。武人為于大君.

眇: blind in one eye. 跛: lame in one foot.

So: able to see, with one eye; able to walk, with one leg — and then treading the tiger's tail, and being bitten.

And the line ends with 武人為于大君 — the martial man acting as the great ruler.

That last clause is the diagnosis, not a separate image. The failure is not weakness. It is a partial capacity taking a whole office.

愬愬

九四 履虎尾,愬愬,終吉.

愬愬: the look of fear and vigilance, holding oneself alert, not letting go.

Same position as line three — on the tiger's tail — and the opposite outcome. Line three is confident with one eye; line four is frightened with both.

The hexagram's argument is in that pair: what survives the tiger is not competence, it is the refusal to relax.

夬履

九五 夬履,貞厲.

說文: 夬,分決也 — to decide, to cut off.

Resolute treading: deciding, cutting through, going straight.

And the judgement is 貞厲 — correct, and dangerous. Not wrong. Correct and dangerous at once, because a decision that cuts is always a decision that cuts something.

視履考祥

上九 視履考祥,其旋元吉.

祥 here is omen, portent (another edition has 詳, to examine in detail).

Look back over the tracks you have made; examine the omens; review what was gained and lost.

旋: 說文 旋,周旋,旌旗之指麾也 — to turn, to return.

行而能回,不是一往不返 — to walk and be able to turn back, rather than going on without return.

Which closes the hexagram: the last instruction is not to walk better. It is to look at the walking.

A test

Take a path you are on — a job, a habit, a way of dealing with someone. Ask where you are putting your weight. 履 is not about courage in the presence of danger; it is about how much of yourself you set down, and where.

Where to read it

License: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.


Previous: hexagram 9, on stopping as the hand of accumulating. Next batch begins with hexagram 11, 泰 — and the question of what "peace" is made of.

Top comments (0)