DEV Community

RUNZEAI
RUNZEAI

Posted on Originally published at q1z2q3-debug.github.io

Hexagram 50, Ding: the hexagram is a drawing of a bronze vessel

鼎。元吉,亨。

Hexagram 50 is about a bronze vessel, and the 彖's first sentence says the hexagram is the vessel.

鼎,象也 — the hexagram is a picture of the thing

鼎 is a pictograph: three legs, two ears, one belly. In the oracle bones it is a drawing of the object.

And 彖's opening sentence, 鼎,象也, has two readings: 象 as "image of the vessel" (the hexagram's lines depict a 鼎), or 象 as "symbol" (the 鼎 symbolizes dynastic power).

This book takes the first, and the correspondence is exact:

  • 初六, one yielding line at the bottom: the legs
  • 九二, 九三, 九四, three solid lines: the belly
  • 六五, yielding in the middle of the top: the ears
  • 上九, solid at the top: the carrying bar

So 象也 is literal. The hexagram is named 鼎 because it looks like a 鼎.

The symbolic sense grows out of that, and the two readings do not conflict.

顛趾,出否

初六 鼎顛趾,利出否.

倒 the vessel over, feet up: 顛趾.
出否: pour out what is stale and foul.

The first act of a new vessel is to turn it upside down and empty it, before anything is put inside.

餗

餗 is the food in the 鼎.

九四 鼎折足,覆公餗,其形渥,凶.

The leg breaks, the duke's food is spilled, and 其形渥 — the shape soaked, dripping, disgraced.

(A variant reading in the 周禮 commentary tradition has 其刑剭, a heavy punishment. Two readings, a large gap: one is humiliation, one is conviction. This book keeps both and uses 形渥 in the text, because the 象 immediately asks 信如何也 — what of your credibility — which is about reputation, not penalty.)

鉉

鉉 is the bar passed through the two ears to carry the vessel. 說文 鉉,舉鼎具也.

However heavy the 鼎, it needs one bar through both ears before it can be lifted.

黃耳,金鉉

六五 鼎黃耳,金鉉,利貞.

Yellow ears, metal bar. Both are the middle: colour of the centre, and a bar of the hardest material.

The line does not add capacity. It makes the vessel liftable.

雉膏

A fat pheasant, the richest dish in the vessel.

九三 鼎耳革,其行塞,雉膏不食 — the ear is altered, the movement blocked, and the good food goes uneaten.

方雨虧悔,終吉 — when the rain comes the regret diminishes, and in the end it is good.

Rain here is the meeting of yin and yang: the fire has been too strong, and a rain adjusts it.

正位凝命

The 象: 君子以正位凝命.

正: to set straight. 凝: to fix, to gather and not scatter.

Not "hold the position." Set the position straight, and fix the mandate onto this vessel.

Position is outside; the mandate is inside. When the position is true, the mandate can settle.

The test

Take an institution or a household you have inherited. Ask the first line's question before any other: has the vessel been turned upside down and emptied? And then the fourth: which is the leg that would break under the weight, and would anyone still trust the food in it.

Where to read it

License: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.


Previous: hexagram 49, on the hide with its hair scraped off. Next: hexagram 51, 震 — the character for thunder, and the ladle of wine that is not spilled.

Top comments (0)