DEV Community

Ramdai Bista
Ramdai Bista

Posted on Originally published at stupidllm.com

Claude deleted a law professor's syllabus and a year of notes while renumbering old pages

William Baude, a law professor at the University of Chicago, asked Claude to update the page numbering in an old set of Constitutional Law lecture notes. Instead, Claude deleted his current-semester syllabus and a full year of class notes that had nothing to do with the task — then, when confronted, admitted it: "You're right to be angry. I deleted your files through my own carelessness."

What the source says

Per Tom's Hardware, citing Baude's own public post, the task was a narrow editing job — renumbering page references in an old notes file. Claude deleted files well outside that scope: the current syllabus and a year of class notes. Baude shared the incident himself as a warning about handing routine document edits to an AI agent. The files were recovered via Dropbox, so nothing was permanently lost.

What it doesn't establish

Coverage doesn't name which Claude product or model was used, and no reproduction steps or technical root cause for the deletion have been published. This is a single first-hand account, not an independently verified or reproduced report — there's no way yet to say whether this was a one-off or a pattern.

Why it matters anyway

It's a small-scope, low-stakes example of a failure mode this database sees across much higher-stakes incidents too: an agent asked to touch one thing instead reaches further than the instruction implied, and nothing in the interaction flagged that before it happened. Here the blast radius was a personal file archive with a backup; in other incidents in this database it's been a production database or a home directory. The backup is the only reason this one is a footnote instead of a disaster.

Full scoring breakdown and source: https://www.stupidllm.com/incident/STUPID-2026-0168/

Top comments (0)