DEV Community

Cover image for The free tier is a countdown, not a price
RealCostLabs for RealCostLabs

Posted on Edited on Originally published at realcostlabs.com AI-assisted

The free tier is a countdown, not a price

Kit's free tier runs to 10,000 subscribers. That is genuinely generous — most tools tap out three orders of magnitude below it.

Then you cross it, and the same 10,000 subscribers cost $139 a month. $1,668 a year, for a list that did not grow by a single person.

Bar chart comparing Kit at $0 in month one and $1,668 per year in month two, both at 10,000 subscribers

I priced 20 marketing tools from their published rate cards, and the free tiers turned out to be the part I had most badly misunderstood. Not because any of it is hidden — every number above is on a public pricing page — but because I was evaluating free tiers the way the pricing page invites you to, which is at today's size.

The ceiling is not set where the cost is

The instinct is that a free tier ends where serving you stops being cheap. Storage, sends, compute — at some point you cost more than you are worth as a prospect, and the vendor asks for money.

That is not where the ceilings sit. 10,000 subscribers is not the point where Kit's marginal cost bites; email is cheap. The ceiling is set where leaving stops being realistic.

By the time you have 10,000 subscribers you have: a signup form embedded on your site, sequences somebody spent a weekend building, tags and segments accumulated over months, integrations wired to your store or your CRM, and deliverability reputation attached to that sending domain. The list is portable. Everything wrapped around it is not.

So the free tier is not a sample. It is a runway with a toll booth at the end, and the length of the runway is calibrated to how long it takes you to build something you will not want to rebuild.

That is not a scandal. It is a rational and completely legal way to acquire customers, and for plenty of people the deal is good. But it means the honest question about a free tier is never "is this enough for me now." It is "what does this cost at the size where it runs out, and what will it cost me to leave at that point."

Four tools where the entry price is $0

In my dataset, thirteen tools have a paid entry tier, and the realistic working plan costs 3.9× the advertised entry price on average.

Four more advertise $0. That does not make them cheap, it makes the multiple undefined rather than small — and it removes them from every comparison table that sorts by starting price, which is most of them.

Four tools whose advertised entry price is zero: Kit, Brevo, Zoho CRM and HubSpot, with what each actually costs at working scale

Zoho CRM is free for three users. The fourth person on your team costs $14 a month on annual billing, $20 on monthly — and that is per seat, so the step from three people to six is not a rounding error. How CRM pricing behaves as teams grow.

HubSpot is the sharpest version of this. The free CRM is real and useful. But the tier where the features people actually reach for live is Sales Hub Professional, and the distance between those two things is the entire commercial design of the product.

Three different things are called "free"

Once I had the data side by side, "free tier" stopped being one category.

A long runway. Kit at 10,000 subscribers. You can run a real newsletter on this for years. The cliff at the end is steep precisely because the runway was long enough for you to build on.

A demo with no clock. Klaviyo's free tier stops at 250 profiles and 500 sends a month. Nobody runs a business on that; it exists so you can see the product work before you pay. Which is fine — it is a trial that does not expire, and it is more honest than a seven-day countdown. Just do not mistake it for a plan. What Klaviyo costs once you are past it.

Free on a different axis. Brevo's free plan is 300 emails a day — a sending limit, not a list limit. You can hold a list of any size for nothing and only pay when you send more. That is a genuinely different bargain, and it is invisible if you compare tools on contact count, because Brevo is not metering contacts at all.

That third case is the one that broke my spreadsheet, and it generalises: comparing free tiers requires knowing what each one is actually counting, which is rarely the same thing.

Across the 17 tools where I checked, four have a free tier you could plausibly run a business on. The rest are demos. Both are legitimate; they are just not the same product and they should not be scored the same way.

How to actually evaluate one

  1. Price the first paid tier at the size you expect in 12–18 months, not today's size. If that number works, the free tier is a gift. If it only works today, you have bought a deadline.
  2. Find out what the meter is before you compare. Subscribers, sends, seats, stored profiles — a free tier on a different axis is not a better deal or a worse one, it is a different deal.
  3. Estimate the exit before you enter. Not "can I export my data" — you almost always can. But how many hours of rebuilding sequences, re-embedding forms, re-wiring integrations and re-warming a sending domain. That number is the real switching cost, and it is what the ceiling was chosen to exceed.
  4. Treat a very generous ceiling as information, not generosity. A tool that gives you 10,000 subscribers for nothing has done the arithmetic on what you will have built by the time you get there.
  5. Check whether free is a plan or a trial. 250 profiles is a trial. 10,000 subscribers is a plan. The pricing page calls both of them "Free".

None of this means avoid free tiers. I use several. It means the decision you are making when you pick one is a 12-month decision disguised as a zero-risk one, and the only way to see that is to price the tier above the one you are joining.

If you want to do that arithmetic without reading twenty rate cards, I built the calculator — pick your category and your scale and it prices the tools at your size rather than at their entry tier.


I run RealCostLabs, where I rebuild SaaS pricing from published rate cards and price it at usage levels real businesses actually hit. Figures above are from published rate cards in mid-2026; vendors change prices, so check before you buy.

Top comments (0)