DEV Community

Richard C
Richard C

Posted on AI-assisted

How to make Amazon, Etsy, and eBay main product photos that meet the rules

AI-Assisted

AIL Studio

A rejected main image is usually a small problem: the background is cream instead of white, the file is too small to zoom, the product sits like a postage stamp in the middle of the frame, or someone added a badge the marketplace does not allow. Amazon, Etsy, and eBay are close enough that one good photo can cover them, but they are not the same. This is a checklist for the main product photo — the one in search and at the top of the listing.

The details below come from each platform’s public help pages and Seller Central posts, checked in November 2026. Help articles move. If a listing is rejected, trust the site’s current image policy over anything written here.

What “white” actually means

Amazon’s main image is the strictest of the three. Seller Support has repeated the same line in public threads: the main product image must have a pure white background with RGB color values 255, 255, 255. That wording appears in Failed to add product photo, in the product image aspect ratio thread, and again when sellers cannot add a photo (do not let add a product).

RGB 255, 255, 255 is not “looks white on my phone.” A warm wall, indoor bulbs on paper, or a JPEG saved from a light-gray canvas will land around 245–252. After you edit, click a corner pixel. If it is not 255, 255, 255, flatten the photo onto a true white canvas and export again.

eBay is softer. Adding pictures to your listings and Take great photos say white backgrounds are generally best, with an uncluttered white or neutral backdrop. That is guidance, not Amazon’s hard RGB rule. You can reuse the Amazon file on eBay.

Etsy does not require a white background. A clean white shot is fine as one listing image, as long as you also follow the authenticity rule below.

How big the file should be

Amazon. Public support posts put the floor at 500 pixels on the longest side (sometimes written as 500 × 500). Zoom starts at at least 1,000 pixels on the longest side; “optimal is 1600+,” and support has recommended 2000 × 2000 for zoom (the failed photo thread; also see What’s New in 2026 for the size floor). Amazon does not require a square, but a 2000 × 2000 JPEG clears both zoom and fill. JPEG is preferred; stay under 10 MB.

eBay. Adding pictures, Take great photos, and the picture policy put the minimum around 500 × 500 (the policy says at least 500 pixels on the longest side). The recommendation is about 1600 × 1600. The same help page says 1:1 or 16:9 photos generally look best, so a square 1600 file plus an optional 1600 × 900 companion covers both. Uploads can be up to about 12 MB.

Etsy. Requirements and Best Practices for Images in Your Etsy Shop recommends a width and height of at least 2000 pixels. The first photo should be at least 635 × 635 so it does not sink in search, and that first photo should be horizontal or square. Easy traps: transparent PNGs are not supported (empty areas turn black), and files larger than about 1 MB may stall on a slow connection.

A set that meets those recommendations: Amazon 2000 × 2000, eBay 1600 × 1600 (plus 1600 × 900 if you want the wide crop), and Etsy 2000 × 2000.

Product fill: don’t leave the item floating

Amazon staff restated the main-image fill rule in the aspect-ratio thread: the product must fill at least 85% of the frame. The 2026 photography standards discussion puts it at 85–100%.

After you place the cutout on a white canvas, the longest side of the product should reach about 85% of that canvas. On a 2000-pixel square, that is roughly 1,700 pixels, centered. If you can see a large empty field around the item, scale it up.

Etsy crops thumbnails into more than one shape, so a little extra margin (closer to 75% fill) helps the item survive those crops. That is a practical choice, not an Etsy-published percentage. eBay does not publish an 85% rule; filling most of the frame still looks better in search than a distant shot.

What you may not add

Amazon’s main-image list, quoted in do not let add a product, bans text, logos, borders, watermarks, and extra graphics. Show the entire product, only what the buyer receives, and one view of one unit. Lifestyle shots and “what’s in the box” graphics belong on secondary images.

eBay is in the same spirit. Adding pictures and the picture policy ban badges, logos, copyright notices, watermarks, extra text, artwork, marketing material, and borders.

A soft drop shadow can make a cutout look less like a sticker, but it tints pixels Amazon wants at RGB 255, 255, 255. Skip the shadow on the Amazon main image. If you want one, use it on a secondary photo or on a marketplace that does not require a measured white field.

Etsy’s real-photo rule

This is the rule a white-background export cannot replace. Etsy’s image requirements say a listing must include at least one unedited photo of the actual item against a real background. Editing — including removing or swapping a background — is allowed on other images, as long as the item still looks like what the buyer will receive.

So Etsy needs two files, not one: keep a straight photo of the real object in its real setting, and you may also upload a clean white-background shot as another image. If every photo is an edited studio cutout, you are missing the authenticity image, even when the cutouts are honest pictures of your own work.

A repeatable way to shoot and export

Photograph the actual product, not a similar stock image. Window light or two cheap lights beats a yellow lamp on one side and a blue window on the other. A white foam board opposite the window fills shadows. Shoot a little larger than you need; it is easier to crop than to invent detail.

Remove the background in whatever editor you already use, paste the cutout onto RGB 255, 255, 255, and check a corner pixel. Scale the product to about 85% of the frame for Amazon and eBay; leave a bit more room if the same file will be an Etsy first photo. Export JPEGs at 2000 × 2000 (Amazon and Etsy) and 1600 × 1600 (eBay), plus 1600 × 900 if you want eBay’s wide option. Do not stamp a price, shop name, or watermark on these main files.

Before you upload: Is the background truly 255, 255, 255? Is the whole product visible? Is there any text? Is the file big enough for zoom? For Etsy, is there still an unedited, real-background photo of the actual item in the same listing?

If you want that export in one step, Listing Photo Set on Poe will place a product photo on a pure white canvas and return the common marketplace sizes; you try it there and spend Poe points to run it.

Top comments (2)

Collapse
 
hiredov profile image
Dov at HireDov •

Useful distinction between a reusable clean hero and Etsy’s required real-item shot. One workflow that saves rework: keep the untouched camera original as the source of truth, then create channel-specific exports from it rather than overwriting the only file. A small asset checklist per SKU—marketplace, required background, crop, minimum dimensions, allowed overlays, and last-checked date—makes handoffs much less fragile. I’d also preview the thumbnail on a phone; a compliant full-size image can still turn into an unrecognizable speck in search. File names are not an asset-management system (we’ve all met the folder called final-final-2).

Collapse
 
richardc_ailstudio profile image
Richard C •

Thanks, that's a good way to put it. Keeping the untouched original is what saves the most rework, since it's the one file you can't recreate later, and the per-SKU checklist is a smart addition for handoffs.