Publishers have suspected it for two years: when Google answers the question itself, fewer people click through to the websites that wrote the answer. Now a randomized experiment has put a number on it — about 40%.
The study, a working paper by Saharsh Agarwal of the Indian School of Business and Ananya Sen of Carnegie Mellon, gave US desktop Chrome users a browser extension that randomly hid AI Overviews for one group and left them visible for the other. Over two weeks of real searches in January and February 2026, with 1,065 participants, the group that saw Overviews averaged 0.37 clicks to outside websites per search, against 0.62 for the group that could not see them. A 39.8% drop. Searches ending with no outbound click at all rose from 54% to 73%.
A second, separate preregistered experiment with 1,100 people found the same direction: removing AI Overviews and AI Mode raised publisher clicks. Two experiments, different designs, one conclusion.
The details sharpen the picture. The loss was concentrated in informational searches — the research questions people ask before buying. Across all searches, the authors estimate Overviews cost websites about 18.5% of the organic clicks they get from Google. And the share keeps growing: DataForSEO shows AI Overviews on 61.43% of tracked US keywords in August 2026, up from 5.93% in September 2024. Chartbeat data for the Reuters Institute shows Google search traffic to 2,500+ news sites down by a third in a year, with small publishers down 60% over two years.
Here is the detail that stings most: while organic clicks fell about 40%, ad clicks did not change at all. The lost clicks were not low-value ones either — bounce rates, quick exits, and time on site showed no measurable difference between the groups. Visitors who did click behaved exactly the same; there were just far fewer of them. Search is becoming less dependable as a route outward for everyone who is not paying Google.
What can publishers do? Google runs an invitation-only AI contribution pilot for roughly 100 publishers — not a plan for most sites. Search Console's generative AI performance report shows how often your pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode, but not clicks or earnings. The industry's answer, generative engine optimization, has thin evidence that it compensates for the loss. Being cited inside an answer does not pay the bills the way a visit used to.
The old bargain — write good content, rank well, get the click — is breaking. The durable answer is readers who come directly: newsletters, loyal audiences, subscriptions, content worth returning for. Google's AI answers are not going away, and this experiment shows exactly what they cost the open web.
Limits, stated plainly: the paper is not yet peer-reviewed, it covered desktop only, and it observed people for two weeks. Even so, a randomized trial is the best evidence anyone has produced — and it points one way.
Read the full article, with the complete numbers, on Rohan Tech Official: https://rohantechofficial.com/tech-news/google-ai-overviews-cut-outbound-clicks-40-percent/
Top comments (0)