I will start by committing product management dissent: Most prioritization frameworks are ineffective; at least in the world we live in today. I spent 7-8 years religiously using RICE scores, built beautiful spreadsheets and color-coded everything. At the time, it felt very smart.
Then I did something on my team at the time: I tracked what we built vs what the frameworks said we should build. And I found the match rate to be 23%. This means we were ignoring our own peculiar situation, 77% of the time.
If you are a Product Manager reading this, you have done the same thing:
- Calculated RICE scores
- Sorted by the highest score
- Looked at the list
- Thought to yourself “That can’t be right”
- Build what you were going to build anyway
- Update the scores to justify your decision
I hope you know most PMs are not using frameworks to make decisions, but using them to justify decisions they already made. I believe it’s theater, a performance and not patterned after applicable realities. And most people still persist in making this mistake.
The day I burned it all down
This was in November 2020 during quarterly planning. I remember a PM was presenting yet another framework. It was 45 minutes of formulas, weighted scores and confidence intervals. Then I raised a question: “What would happen if we just built what customers are literally begging for?”
Silence.
“No, seriously. What if we just... listened?”
More silence.
So, I tried it.
The incredibly simple system that changed everything
Here’s my step by step approach:
Step 1: What are customers SCREAMING about? I do not mean asking, nor suggesting. I am referring to the customers who are SCREAMING. Check support tickets. Read tweets from frustrated customers. Watch rage-quit videos. If 50+ people are losing their minds about the same thing, that is your list.
Step 2: Can we fix it in 2 weeks? Not “can we fix it perfectly.” Can we make it 50% less terrible in 2 weeks? Yes? Do it. No? Break it into smaller problems.
Step 3: Did revenue move? Now you have shipped it. Has this moved the needle marginally? Keep going. Is your Revenue flat? Now you have the next problem to solve, look for the friction and fix it. Did you find revenue dipped? Revert and learn.
That’s it. That’s the entire system.
What Happened When We Stopped Pretending
Q1 2021 (with frameworks): 12% revenue growth
Q2 2021 (first quarter without) 47% revenue growth
Q3 2021: 84% revenue growth
Q4 2021: 112% revenue growth
Q1 2022: 340% total growth year-over-year
We built LESS but grew MORE.
Why? Because we stopped building what we thought was important and started fixing what was broken.
The Features We Killed (That Everyone Said We Needed)
- AI-powered dashboard (6 months of work) → Killed
- Advanced analytics suite → Killed
- Mobile app → Killed
- Slack integration → Killed
- 20+ “innovative” features → All killed
The features we shipped instead:
- Fixed the abandoned search that had not worked since early 2020
- Made export actually export (revolutionary, I know)
- Stopped logging people out randomly
- Made the site load in under 3 seconds
- Added a phone number to call when stuff breaks
Was it easy? No. Smooth execution? Definitely no. Did customers care? Yes! Our dashboards trended rightwards.
Why I believe your prioritization is pure theater
You are not using data. You are using data theater. That confidence score in your RICE calculation is made up. That reach estimate was a wild guess. That impact score was based on vibes.
A lot of product teams have created elaborate frameworks to feel scientific about guessing. Meanwhile, your customers are TELLING YOU EXACTLY WHAT TO BUILD. You just don’t want to hear it because it’s boring.
The Truth That Will Set You Free
Your customers don’t want innovation. They want their stuff to work. Your investors don’t care about your framework. They care about revenue. Your team doesn’t need another planning session. They need to ship something. Anything.
Stop “prioritizing” using frameworks. Start shipping. Stop scoring. Start listening. Start fixing.
The best framework is no framework. Build what people are screaming for. Charge more for it. Repeat.
Everything else is theater.
Top comments (0)