DEV Community

Cover image for How to optimize your website for AI search: what 3 experts fix first
Jeremy Rivera
Jeremy Rivera

Posted on Originally published at 2thetopdesign.com

How to optimize your website for AI search: what 3 experts fix first

You don't need a new website to show up in ChatGPT. You need the one you have to say, in plain text, what you do, where you do it and why somebody should trust you. That's it. Google's own guidance on AI features says there are no special requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode: the page has to be indexed, readable as text, and the structured data has to match what's actually on the page. Most small business sites miss on at least one of those, and fixing it rarely takes a rebuild.

2theTop title card reading Fix your website before AI search sizes you up, what 3 experts check first, next to a mock web page with a clear H1, prices and process, and LocalBusiness schema

We already covered the off-site side (your Business Profile, reviews and local mentions) in local SEO in the age of AI. This one is about the website itself.

AI assistants read your website before they recommend you

When somebody asks ChatGPT or Google's AI Mode "who does roof repair in Franklin?", the assistant runs searches in the background, reads the pages it finds, and writes an answer. Google calls this a "query fan-out". If your service page is a stock photo, a slider and the words "Quality You Can Trust", there's nothing for it to read. Your competitor with a boring page that lists prices, process and service area gets quoted instead.

Here's what that means for you: the same things that made a page rank in Google for the last ten years are the things that get it read by an AI assistant now. The difference is that an assistant is less forgiving of vague pages, because it's trying to pull out a specific answer.

Five website fixes that help Google and AI assistants at the same time

Numbered list of five website fixes for AI search: 1 say what each page is about, 2 one page per service, 3 text a machine can read, 4 structured data that matches the page, 5 proof you did the work
Source: Google Search Central, "AI features and your website" (checked 18 Nov 2026). Order is 2theTop's judgement.

  1. Say what each page is about. Your H1 should be a short sentence that names the service and the place, like "Roof repair in Nashville with same-week estimates". One word ("Roofing") tells a reader, and a machine, almost nothing. Our on-page SEO guide covers where the rest of the words go.
  2. Give every service its own page. One page that "does it all" can't answer a specific question. Each service page should cover the price range, the process, the timeline, the area you serve and who it's not a fit for.
  3. Put the facts in text a machine can read. If your prices live in a PDF, your hours in an image or your service list inside a slider, an assistant may never see them. Google lists "making sure that important content is available in textual form" as a best practice.
  4. Use structured data that matches the page. LocalBusiness markup helps, but only when it says exactly what the visible page says: same name, address, phone and hours. Google says you don't need any special AI schema or AI text files.
  5. Show proof you actually did the work. Real project photos, named neighborhoods, reviews that describe the job. Generic copy that could sit on any competitor's site gives an assistant no reason to pick you.

If you want to see how these mistakes cost you leads in plain Google results too, read web design mistakes that hurt SEO.

What 3 experts fix first on a small business website

I asked three people who work on very different parts of this one question each: a technical SEO whose team moved 5.4 million URLs across 180 domains for SB Nation without a traffic crash, a content marketer who's spent years writing pages that bring in leads, and a coach who teaches small business owners to run their own WordPress SEO. Their answers are below, in their own words.

Tory Gray on the technical check that comes first

Tory runs The Gray Dot Company, which handles technical SEO, migrations and what she calls agentic readiness: deciding what AI agents should and shouldn't be able to do on your site. We asked her what one technical thing she'd check first on a 10 to 50 page WordPress site. She said there are really two, so here are both.

Start by checking the raw HTML of your key pages, before any JavaScript runs. Most AI crawlers don’t render JavaScript, so content loaded by page builders, tabs, sliders, or lazy-loading scripts can be invisible to them. If your services, pricing, and contact details aren’t in that initial HTML, fix that first.

Make sure you aren’t blocking AI bots by accident. Security plugins, CDN bot settings, or a "whoops" robots.txt rule can all shut out crawlers from ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity. If they can’t fetch the page, nothing else you’ve optimized matters.

Tory Gray, Founder and CEO, The Gray Dot Company (LinkedIn)

Alison Ver Halen on a page that gets quoted and still sells

Alison runs AV Writing Services and wrote Content Marketing Made Easy. By her account, her first client, a law firm, told her that six months of her blog posts had brought in 75,000 dollars of business. We asked her what separates a service page an AI assistant will quote from one that actually brings in a lead.

I think the answer to accomplishing both is ensuring the service page a) is easy to read and scan, because both humans and robots scan to find the information most relevant to them, and b) answers the questions prospects are asking. A service page that addresses common objections and FAQs is more likely to put a prospect at ease, making them feel more confident in buying from/hiring the company. There's also been a lot of discussion around the fact that the chatbots love websites with FAQ lists because people are increasingly asking those questions of their chatbot before they click through to a website. So if a chatbot can find the answers to those questions on your website, it's more likely to use it as a source when providing answers for their users. The key to converting leads from the chatbots is to make sure the content answers the questions people have in the later stages of the buyer journey. If people are just looking for information, they're less likely to click away from their chatbot. But if they're starting to comparison shop and consider pros and cons of investing in a solution to their problem, that's when that visibility really counts.

Alison Ver Halen, President, AV Writing Services (LinkedIn)

Warren Laine-Naida on letting the bots in first

Warren is a digital skills coach who teaches web, marketing and SEO, including to people running their own WordPress sites. We asked him what he has a student fix first so ChatGPT and Google's AI answers can use their pages.

First, let's check that the bots can actually get in to the website. That means ‘Discourage search engines’ is unticked, robots.txt allows Googlebot and OAI-SearchBot, and your host isn’t quietly blocking AI crawlers. Then we should look our page headings and structure are offering the machines what they look for: valuable, unique, non-commodity content.

Warren Laine-Naida, Digital Skills Coach, Web/Marketing/SEO, seo-coaching.eu (X)

Notice that two of the three start in the same place: can the crawler get in at all? Check that before you touch a single heading.

Redesign or repair: a quick test before you spend

Owners call us all the time asking for a new website because "we're not showing up in AI". Sometimes that's right. More often it isn't. Run through this before you sign anything:

Redesign or repair checklist: repair if you can edit headings and text, services have their own pages, the site loads fast on a phone and leads still come in; rebuild if key text lives in images or an uneditable builder, one page sells every service, nobody can add schema, or the platform is out of support

  • Can you (or whoever runs the site) edit the headings and page text without calling a developer?
  • Does each service already have its own page, even a thin one?
  • Does the site load in a few seconds on a phone?
  • Do leads still come in through the site at all?

If you answered yes to most of those, repair it. Rewrite the H1s, split out the service pages, move the facts out of images and add schema that matches. If you answered no to most of them, a rebuild is probably cheaper in the long run, and that's what our web design work is built around.

Optimizing your website for AI search starts with one page

Pick the service that makes you the most money. Open that page. Would a stranger know what you do, where, roughly what it costs and why you're the one to call, without scrolling past a slider? If not, that's your first fix, and it's the same fix that'll help you in Google tomorrow. If you'd rather have someone look at it with you, start with a 2theTop SEO audit. Or just get in touch with us.


Originally published on 2theTop Web Design & Marketing.

Top comments (0)